[VOTE] SotW #71

[C4E]

SIGNATURE OF THE WEEK #71
-Idea Generator-
v o t i n g - t h r e a d | d e a d l i n e : S A T U R D A Y, O C T O B E R 6, 2 0 0 7
--------
G U I D E L I N E S :
Choose three tags with highest priority. The first one being the one you like the most, and two more that follow that. The letters above the tags signify which tag you are voting for, so remember to number your votes with a corresponding letter, with comments and critiques. No, you can not vote for yourself.
-------
CANVAS

[Evrae_Valkyrion]

You still apply that 'no vote, disqualificate' rule?

#1: F
+ ...The green complies nicely with the gray... -stares-
- What's with the random white on the left?

#2: H
+ Looks fun~ and the effects look great too.
- Hmm, a little more light, no?

#3: tie between B and E

B: +the coloring looks cutish. Like a kindergartener's colouring, but with better picture and smoother colouring.
- Umm...text...

E: + It seriously match the topic, and it's sickly good for some unknown reason...
- Yes...it has its own attraction...but it lacks something...hmm...

================

I really cant' see anything in D, by the way.

[Cin]

Originally Posted by Evrae_Valkyrion

You still apply that 'no vote, disqualificate' rule?

...disqualify? XD

Anyway, voting:

1: H
+ I like the theme and the tag as a whole, nice depth.
- The double focal points messes with the depth. And it confuses you as to where you're really supposed to be looking.

2: I
+ Nice use of sprite and background.
- The colors are a bit funky and it's a little bright

3: A
+ This was an okay sig with a lot of potential
- White background ftl

[???]

A- Gets the theme across magnificently, and is more of an original piece, something I tend not to see alot. I think it was done with another program. The white bg doesn't bother me at all, everything else replaces this, and honestly I don't believe a background would fit well with it.

B- Another original one in my eyes. The only reason it wasn't first is because the theme wasn't exercized as much, while it pulls off a paper theme, I don't see how it fits as a game. The drawing is great and the theme title is displayed well.

I- The lighting seems just balanced enough, the colors vary nicely and were chosen as well as used nicely. Not much else wrong in my eyes.

Great tags this week people, keep it up.

[Mikail]

1. A - It's original and really connects with the title "Artificial Music Club". When I see that phrase, I too see robots rocking out lol. The only thing I don't like is the yellow-orange on the bass drum. Love the simplicity feeling of it

2. B- Love the artistic feeling it gives. Nice way to connect Origami to to revolutionary paper game. Love the simplicity feeling of it

2. F - Love how the green stands out to give a sense of nucluar/toxic. The limited color also makes the image as a whole stand out.

[Ken]

A - Need I say more than what's already been said?
F - I love the simplicity of it all >:
D - While not the best, it makes use of it's theme without any stock of sorts. Great execution.

[♥]

G- Love the colors used, but the green irks me a bit.
B - awesome
D - nice smudging.

[Aqua]

1. F - I love the way the color accents the black and white. It seems to emphasize the theme of the piece.

2. I - I think the mood really fits the title

3. A - I also have to say it is really original, also I think it leads to a good eye movement pattern

[C4E]

A. Great creativity and it really gets the theme across. one of my favorite tags ive ever seen for sure.

B. also very good, nice work. great job getting the theme across.

E. i dont know if you made the stock yourself or what, but it really fit well. didnt like the borders really though.

[Silh]

A - love how this one's been set up
F - for the same reason Evrae stated
G - scribbles make it less appealing than the other two, but it's awwwwwwwwwwrite

[Epic Nature]

A-Set up great, love the originality of it
F-Same as Aqua
B-coloring

[Gamergirl89]

F--The simplicity of it.

E--Its quite interesting. I would love to know if u made that stock or not.

A--Very creative and I like the somewhat sketchy look of it (+ the line clusters and line weight), though it could do without that bright a** spot of light on the drums.

[C4E]

Thanks for letting me know.
reuploaded to imageshack.

[C4E]

come on guys.
this needs more votes.

[Dark Riku]

A. Not bad, but the bg could use something more than just white.

B. Typo could've been better, but the tag blends pretty well on the left side.

F. The simplicity is rather nice, and the typo is good.