Signature of the Week #17

[Prodigy]

All entries from now on are OFF LIMITS

Start the voting.

[Onewingedangel6]

1 - Ecs

2 - Libra

3 - C_U

[monkeybutt]

My votes (EVen if they dont count, Just voting. xP)

1. skilled keyblade (That is just SO great for a first sig, I HAVE to give you first)

2. darren (Great job, very sparkly)

3. Permintor (I liked the face thing you added, made it different from the rest.)

Everyone else: D: I didnt really pick ___ and ___ and __ because they all just looked the same to me. THe point of everyone having the same stock, is to make YOURS stand out more.

Great job everyone!

[Mr.SpaceShipDriver]

1 - Ecs..just looks smexy like always)
2 -skilled keyblade..(i agree with monky very good for a first)
3 - C_U(colors match stock nicely..gj....and ZOMG its not uber bright for once)

Just my two cents on how I see the voting going:
Yall are voting on a tag that isn't as good as the others, just because it's one of his firsts. This is SoTW, where the product is being judged, not the experience.

[Stryder_sdc]

I really wanna cry, i have no votes so far

[monkeybutt]

Originally Posted by tux_

Just my two cents on how I see the voting going:
Yall are voting on a tag that isn't as good as the others, just because it's one of his firsts. This is SoTW, where the product is being judged, not the experience.

Well, his product was uniquely made, and done excellently. And yes, I look at experience. Unlike you I take everything into consideration, and will not vote for people who make the same bland sigs every week.

Stryder, try again in the next SOTW. ^^ You'll keep getting better.

Well, if that happens then any n00b can make a craptastic tag, say it's his first, and win?
EVEN THOUGH there are people who also try and produce something better?
You make no sense

[monkeybutt]

Originally Posted by tux_

Well, if that happens then any n00b can make a craptastic tag, say it's his first, and win?
EVEN THOUGH there are people who also try and produce something better?
You make no sense

You have really bad reasoning. Even if it wasnt his first sig, I would still have put him in the top three? Why? Because I compeltely believe that ecstacy' CU's etc (which I lub them all, but I know they understand ;D), their sigs look almost exactly the same. And I am not going to bother voting for that. They may have put in effort, but that doesnt mean, just because they are older in graphics that they "tried to make something better", if anything, the person who made their "first sig" tried to make something.

If you wish to argue with me, carry on, I'm not even a judge.

[Stryder_sdc]

well next time then ill say this is my first sig and maybe ill win if thats your reasoning

[Dark Niwa]

I mildly agree with monkey

those sigs weren't so good but iam kinda tired of seein the same top 3
but hey what can you do (damn i hate you pscs2! maybe i don't w/e anyway!)
Only ecs and C_U's look amazingly alike... actually the stock is like milimeters apart in each
libras does look different

but i won't lie any say randomly made tags are nice but i love changes just my 2 cents

I think there should be different divisions because the poster above me seems to be dissapointed in getting no votes maybe thats why all the people with experience come to this thread every week and win

[Banishing Blade]

Originally Posted by Stryder_sdc

well next time then ill say this is my first sig and maybe ill win if thats your reasoning

You've missed the point.

One quick note: Monkey's opinion doesn't count towards the SotW this week, thererfore you are all arguing for no reason. Do it through PM or IM.

The point of the SotW is to promote originality and creativity. Both Ecstacy's and C_U's (while still being decent tags) lack those. If you don't like something about the SotW this week, then do something about it next week.

Now, no more posting unless you're a judge.

[Ecstacy]

eh i'll prolly get teh warning for this but idk how mine is like CU's <.< i didnt smudge...i didnt use the color he used...i didnt put the light source in the same place he did...and i cant find any distortion anywhere on his tag <.< only thing i see the same is the \o/ <--- likeness of the tags....and thats how most of the entries are so...yeah...

[Stryder_sdc]

i think maybe we should all just calm down then and let someone post all entries in one post, after which no one except the 3 judges can post their decisions, oh to hell with it, ill do it, heres all entries with names in order
darkriku14
Libra
Keyblade416
Cloud Unchained
Ecstacy
VersionX
Raito
Stryder_sdc
Perminator
Darren
Skilled Keyblada

[Onewingedangel6]

Stryder either way stop trying to make urself win u aint!! 2 judges already voted so their aint no point in doin that already .. all we needs is Hp to vote then it's done and Ecs is gonna win eitha way cause me and STO already voted fo him