The Namine Topic 2.0

[Alw3000]

i think shes from twilight town.

[Soren]

Honestly, I feel sorry for her. But ya know, bein a which, she's gotta have a power source, right? So are powers from the darkness, like Axel and Marluxia, from the Light, Like Mickey and Sora, or from the Twilight? I thought it might have been darkness because of where she was stuck. but do we really know what gives this particular "nonexistent one" her strength?

[exed_out__]

Originally Posted by misai

I think I mentioned a theory somewhere else on this.

Perhaps Namine's magic was futile against the unknowns.

Here's what I think.
Marluxia and them all
= unknowns
= therefore, they're the 'nobodies'/'nonexistent ones'
= therefore, they have no hearts
= therefore, no 'solid' memories
= because nobodies do not have memories
= which means Namine can't do anything about it.

I doubt she came willingly. Why couldn't she have just met Sora herself?

If the organization members ahd no hearts tehn they would automatically be turned into heartless.

They are niether dark nor light. theyre just plain old mysterious bad guys who mess around with sora.

[Oracle]

Nobodies are mere shells, lacking both a heart, and a soul. They're just shells. Nothing more. Lets get back on topic people.

My theory is that Namine is Kairi's Shell. I'm still a bit doubtful about it though... She said she was Kairi's shadow, she has the same appearance (except for hair and clothes) as Kairi, and she seems just as powerful as Kairi. But I thought her heart returned to her body when Sora stabbed himself with the Dark Keyblade... Thats why I doubt my own theory, but I can't think of anything else that sounds logical.

Originally Posted by Darkness Riku

Namine is Kairi's opposite.Namine even says that"I'm her shadow".

maybe the shadow of her heart?.....

[Riku-Keyblade]

Originally Posted by Oracle

Nobodies are mere shells, lacking both a heart, and a soul. They're just shells. Nothing more. Lets get back on topic people.

My theory is that Namine is Kairi's Shell. I'm still a bit doubtful about it though... She said she was Kairi's shadow, she has the same appearance (except for hair and clothes) as Kairi, and she seems just as powerful as Kairi. But I thought her heart returned to her body when Sora stabbed himself with the Dark Keyblade... Thats why I doubt my own theory, but I can't think of anything else that sounds logical.

She is not kairi's shell! yes She did say she was kairi's shadow but not because she is her shell she meant it in sora's memories. She took out kairi from his memories and replaced the memories of kairi with fake memories of Namine. Thats how she was kairi's shadow not because she is kairi's shell. To the poster who said that Namine would disguise herself as BHK that is wrong because it has been said that in the Jump Festa Trailer Namine is seen talking to BHK. Namine is a witch who was captured by the Organization to do their dirty work.

[Sora101101]

i dunno. why would she work for the organization? she seems nice. and remember, axel said, "Namine', do you see Marluxia here?" and let her go. maybe she was forced? but then where did the organization find her? ?????????

[Riku-Keyblade]

She was obviously forced to help Marluxia in his plan to mess with Sora. Axel most likely said that because he knew it would lead to the fall of Marluxia and Axel wanted that because he believed that Larxene and Marluxia were traitors. What do you mean by "Where did they find her?" . If you mean where did they capture her, no one knows because it was never mentioned but Marluxia was the one who did it, since it was his plan to use her powers.

(PS-Sora101101 Thanks for posting something no one barely posts in this thread.)
EDIT:

Originally Posted by Oracle

Nobodies are mere shells, lacking both a heart, and a soul. They're just shells. Nothing more. Lets get back on topic people.

Actually your wrong there Oracle, Nobodies are shells but they have a body AND a soul my proof is Ansem Report 13.

Originally Posted by Ansem Report 13

When the heart casts off the flesh, where does the body go?

Heart and soul are separate, and the spirit remains in the body. But can we assume that the leftover body and soul perish?

Certainly when the heart changes into a Heartless the body disappears.

However, that is only this world's story; in another world, mightn't they change forms like the Heartless and exist there?

If we take that to be the case, there must be a you other than yourself existing somewhere.

An existence neither of darkness nor of light.
An in-between existence.
Cast off by the heart, a mere shell, one who begrudges both the darkness and the light.

This mystery cannot be easily resolved.
The relationship between the heart and the flesh is a complex one.

But since we exist here, they cannot be termed as existent.
Therefore I shall call them...

"The non-existent ones."

[Alw3000]

i posted about BHK and Namine. I agree that Namine is not Kairi's shell. She meant that she was not who he thought she was, but rather like a dark version of Kairi in his memories, because she was feeling guilty about the whole thing any way.

[kingdom_hk]

sorry if this was asked but how do u pronounce her name?

[Riku-Keyblade]

Naminé(Nah-mee-nay) although my french teacher insists that in english you would pronounce it Nah-mi-nad lol. The first one is correct by the way.
This thread is so dead I decided to make up my own little theory.
Riku ditches his love for Kairi and goes out with Naminé

[dark_riku05]

CAUTION: WILD THEORY WHICH IS MERELY THEORY!!!!
What if Namine is just a girl who was lonely and created all this? I mean, she had the capability and the motive. She was possibly shocked at the end when Sora chose to have memories with Kairi, because the whole thing was just to meet a hero...Just a theory, I mind you.

[KeybladeKid1127]

Ya but if you finished the ending you know that Sora made a promise to never forget her and when Sora awakes from that white cacoon they will thank namine because jmeny wrote in his journal to "Thank Namine" and then when they thank her she will tell them what happen in the castle. That will give Sora a memory about namine.

[Dark_Kairi23]

Theory:
When Kairi lost her heart she did not turn into a heartless. BUT she did get a shell. But since she didn't become a Heartless her shell was all messed up and Namine was formed. It's a stupid theory but hey I want to post!


(Does anyone know how to do the e' thingy. I feel stupid asking that but I've never had any reason to use the e thing.)

[Riku-Keyblade]

Alt+0233=é
Anyways That doesnt work. When Kairi got her heart back she was completed and that means that the nobodie would disappear. Like when
*Spoilers to KeybladeKid*
Ansem took over Riku's body he sent riku's heart to Kingdom Hearts and ansem used Riku's Body/Shell to get his own physical appearance back. When you defeat him Riku gets his body/shell back and then you see him. So if Riku had a 'nobody' appear it would be gone because he then was complete.
*End of Spoilers...I think*
Well i hope that helps, im not very good at the explanation things.
To dark_riku05 do you mean that Naminé made everything like the Organization or do you mean all she did was do the memory switching because thats all she realy did.