Shell theory

[Nemesis]

Originally Posted by Eternal Wanderer

I would have explained, but it looks like KL beat me to it. A shell CANNOT wield a keyblade, because a keyblade is to do with the heart and only those with hearts can wield one. I'm tired of these shell theories personally.

dude. just dude. seriously. give the shell theory some slack. While i dont personally belive it, its definatly at least a possiblitie. well the BHK part anyway
Namine i dont agree with.

[Angel Shards]

Originally Posted by .:KL:.

All the shell theories are a bunch of bull. And below I WILL PROVE ALL of them wrong:

BHK: Sora's Shell

In KH, Sora used the Heart Unlocker to unlock Kairi's heart. In the process his heart was plunged into darkness and he became a shadow heartless. But with Kairi's love and wanting to protect Sora, he was changed back to normal...

Now there are 2 conclusions:
1. Kairi brought ALL of Sora back when she changed him back into himself.
2. Kairi only brought back Sora's heart and gave his heart a physical appearance while his body and soul are still running around.

Now...Some people say that the BHK is Sora's "shell". Which would mean he is just a body and soul.

BUT, You need a heart to wield a keyblade. And if the BHK is Sora's shell then he would just be a body and soul. WITH NO HEART. So how could an empty shell with no heart wield a keyblade? It couldn't. You need a heart. The Keyblade has to do with the heart. Riku lost the keyblade when he chose Darkness over Light. Sora got it because he didn't choose the darkness but remained faithful to the light.

So in conclusion: You need a heart to wield a keyblade. Shells don't have hearts. So if the BHK is Sora's shell then he can't wield the keyblade.

Now do you still believe that the BHK is Sora's shell? Just a body and soul without a heart? Well if you do your dumb.
----------------------------------------------
Namine: Kairi's Shell/Shadow

People think Namine is Kairi's shell. Now seriously...HOW DUMB DO YOU HAVE TO GET TO SAY THAT? Whoever claims this must have not played Kingdom Hearts. Now to the people that have played Kingdom Hearts. You should know that Kairi's heart was inside Sora. And you should also know that Maleficent found Kairi's shell/body & soul and gave it to Riku. You get to see it in Neverland and Hallow Bastion. So if you notcied thats all of Kairi, Heart, Shell, and Soul. So how could Namine be her shell?

Now Namine being a shadow of Kairi:

kaizer21 explained it perfectly:

-sighs- As always, am agreeing with KL. Not that I dislike agreeing with KL. YOU BEAT ME TO IT! -glomps- Heh. Anywho....

Nemsis, no offense, but give the shell theory a rest. KL basically pwned you. I don't see how you can still say "it may be a possibility."

It's not.

[Nemesis]

Originally Posted by Keyblade Shards

-sighs- As always, am agreeing with KL. Not that I dislike agreeing with KL. YOU BEAT ME TO IT! -glomps- Heh. Anywho....

Nemsis, no offense, but give the shell theory a rest. KL basically pwned you. I don't see how you can still say "it may be a possibility."

It's not.

You make it sound like i back the idea. to be honest, i dont. he raised a good point, one i can't really argue. but because i dont originally belive in the shell theory to begin with, i was mearly asking a question when i started this. Like i said in my last point, this shell stuff is kinda confusing, but my mind ain't working right yet, so it might just be me

If u read the first question of this thing, i was mearly asking the question as to how does a shell survive without a heart. I like to explore all theories. I dont really have one of my own anymore. I find mine have been used and dispearsed long before my eyes.
Besides, i say anything can be a possiblity cause it could be. the game isn't out yet. I say that to everything. Even Diz not being Ansem in any way shape or form.
But like i said, its mearly possible.