if a nobody kills the person he/she was made from

[cananthegreat]

For instance what if roxas killed sora at the station of calling\??????


Cheers

[Almagest]

That confrontation wasn't physical. It was a battle in Sora's mind (or heart?)

But, if a nobody destroyed their somebody...interesting...maybe they would become the somebody? idk

[Xinjust]

The way I look at it, Sora and Roxas are the same person right? If the somebody or the nobody would kill their other, then the victor would cease to exist.

As in theory if they're the same person; if one dies, the other dies as well.

[Axel Owns]

well, sora and roxas was a unique case.

sora is the only one (that we know of) to have become a heartless then transform back.

and i think that if roxas killed sora, sora would die. nothing would happen to roxas.

[monkeytoeeater]

a nobody cannot fight their original person, as you recall, sora could not awake until roxas came and helped, a person needs their nobody

[akasonic18]

Originally Posted by monkeytoeeater

a nobody cannot fight their original person, as you recall, sora could not awake until roxas came and helped, a person needs their nobody

Not really. Xehanort's Heartless and Xemnas existed at he same time, so you really don't need your other side to exist, just having your other side within you makes you whole again. Just imagine Xehanort's Heartless and Xemnas battling it out, both have been the two strongest bosses in Kingdom Hearts, I don't count Marluxia because I think he's weaker then Xehanort's Heartless.

[Miles Edgeworth]

Originally Posted by cananthegreat

For instance what if roxas killed sora at the station of calling\??????


Cheers

They were in an arena created by their mind of heart. Speaking in KH language, if the Nobody kills his Somebody surely the Somebody's heart will leave the body and the Nobody will claim it as his. Speaking in human language, if one kills his old former self, wouldn't the results be in existence to seize? It's like saying you have 24 years and you kill your young 12 year old self.

[SufferingAngel]

I don't think they could really 'kill' each other, saying in Roxas and Sora's case, but they could 'defeat' each other the way Sora did Roxas.
Point of the matter is that Roxas effectively beat Sora in the normal version where it was an event, and I think he'd have became the 'Somebody' had he landed the finishing blow.
A Somebody isn't 'Sora'. It's 'Sora and Roxas merged together without an Inner Roxas'.
Seeing how the ending of KH2 based said 'Inner Roxas' as fact, I can't even call Sora the 'Somebody' anymore. That calls, however, for battles of dominance as the one we saw at the end of KH2, seeing how Roxas is different than Sora, despite being inside him.

[tazztig]

Well, 1 of the other had 2win because it was a fight between the true keyblade masters....

[keyhole]

Originally Posted by cananthegreat

For instance what if roxas killed sora at the station of calling\??????

Interesting question. In guess if a nobody kills their other. Nothing would happen or the nobody would die too. Good question though

[InfiniteTwilight]

In the case of Roxas possibly killing Sora, Sora would die, but Roxas would remain incomplete.
If Sora had any memories Roxas didn't receive, chances are he wouldn't get those memories
and Sora's heart would just plummet into heck since he probably wouldn't transform into a Heartless.
Then, chances are Roxas would die somehow by some unrelated matter.

I doubt a Nobody would want to kill their possibly still alive Somebody.
They mostly want to become whole and maybe gain more strength then they
had when they were split.

[sonicisblue]

mayby the fight between Sora and Roxas was a mental fight and it was because Roxas was trying to come out. Like they fuse together so they're both in one body that Sora controls. But since they were in the world that never was it could've stirred Roxas's memories and he tries to gain control over their "shared body"

[SufferingAngel]

Originally Posted by sonicisblue

mayby the fight between Sora and Roxas was a mental fight and it was because Roxas was trying to come out. Like they fuse together so they're both in one body that Sora controls. But since they were in the world that never was it could've stirred Roxas's memories and he tries to gain control over their "shared body"

I agree.
[spoiler]I think the reason Roxas 'stirred' wasn't where they were though, but Axel's death.
Him asking Sora why they were chosen by the Keyblade could be understood as
"why did it choose you when you let him die", especially since now that he was inside Sora,
he sort of had a Heart to feel with, both his friendship with Axel and mourning
over his death.[/spoiler]

[Karate]

Originally Posted by cananthegreat

For instance what if roxas killed sora at the station of calling\??????


Cheers

If a nobody destroyed its heartless, it'd become whole when it faded. Confirmed by Nomura. [/thread]

Also death=/=losing your heart.

[Artistry of Schedius]

^what he said...i sort fo agree wid it.coz XH was still alive when Xemnas was alive.we killed XH and looks at xemnas..still alive..so if Roxas kils Sora,ummm..Roxas MIGHT become whole?(dunno why though...)and stay alive.