C'mon, c'mon - Page 2

~~jamal~~ · 05/04/07, 04:10 AM

The stock does not fit in, not blended at all. The lines dont work well, or atleast if you have dark red lines, add some more of that color to parts of the tag. And the blurriness on the right does not look to good, atleast not incorporated well into the tag.

Color Me Evil · 05/04/07, 04:23 AM

Eek, no need to be so harsh. I said I was experimenting, and thank you for pointing out every single thing wrong and not anything that's decent. May I redirect you to this thread.

~~jamal~~ · 05/04/07, 04:27 AM

Um how was I harsh? If I sugercoat everything about your tag, you wont learn. I point out things to work on, no need to get snappy.

Frozen Inferno · 05/04/07, 04:28 AM

jamal, warning. Harsh critique is NOT allowed under any circumstance; even if the person does ask for it, don't give it.

Harsh critique is considered flaming. your relativly new from what I see, so consider yourself lucky this time. And not so much the next.

EDIT: Yeah, you pointed out things wrong. But you did not point out anything good. And that is called harsh critique which is considered... OH~! just read what I said before the edit!

~~jamal~~ · 05/04/07, 04:31 AM

What if I dont find anything good?

darkweilder · 05/04/07, 04:32 AM

^^ good point, you can't always be nice

~~jamal~~ · 05/04/07, 04:35 AM

And I hope you dont think I am being a smartass or anything, I am just curious.

Frozen Inferno · 05/04/07, 04:36 AM

Then say it in a nicer way instead of blantly saying it sucks. Then, after saying it in a nicer way instead of saying everything is just bad, tell her how to fix it. You said many problems, and gave only one possible thing for her to work off of: "...Add some more color".

That falls under just plain bad critique. Tell what colors could be done. Or, tell a possible way to fix this blurriness problem. Tell her how to blend.

Now, go read that thread CME posted religiously. Don't post again until you have it memorized, mkay?

EDIT: Oh trust me, you surpased my thinking your a smartass. Because if your not trying to be one, its surely how you're coming off.

~~jamal~~ · 05/04/07, 04:41 AM

Um wow I can't believe I am having an argument with such a narrow thinking point. If I dont say "IMPROVE YOUR BLENDING" but say "the blending is not good" then I am at fault? If I say the blending is not good, that would automatically tell you, that you should work on that aspect.

Frozen Inferno · 05/04/07, 04:46 AM

No, you clearly don't see what i am saying. Give SUGGESTIONS and TIPS on how for someone to do so. Typing it all in caps would be considered just as much flaming as posting something like what you did.

What your example was is that basic same thing gets different consiquences. No, they don't. Normally, they would A) Get deleted B) Get a warning or C) Get banned for three days. It would no longer be considered flaming if you would just give tips or suggestions as to how to improve!

darkweilder · 05/04/07, 04:49 AM

lol, seriously .... so can you say, "the blending is not good...get better at it, tuts please?" ... good crit?

ps. this isn't a discussion on crits btw, this is CME's sig page?

Color Me Evil · 05/04/07, 01:36 PM

Yeah... this turned into a nice little spam topic. Please take all critique to Sparkle's thread. THANKS.

[CLOSED]

05/04/07, 04:10 AM	#16
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: C'mon, c'mon The stock does not fit in, not blended at all. The lines dont work well, or atleast if you have dark red lines, add some more of that color to parts of the tag. And the blurriness on the right does not look to good, atleast not incorporated well into the tag.

05/04/07, 04:23 AM	#17
Color Me Evil Spy of Atlantis Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Boston Age: 17 Posts: 3,764 Rep Power: 8	Re: C'mon, c'mon Eek, no need to be so harsh. I said I was experimenting, and thank you for pointing out every single thing wrong and not anything that's decent. May I redirect you to this thread.

05/04/07, 04:27 AM	#18
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: C'mon, c'mon Um how was I harsh? If I sugercoat everything about your tag, you wont learn. I point out things to work on, no need to get snappy.

05/04/07, 04:28 AM	#19
Frozen Inferno Awakens the Broken Bride Join Date: Jan 2006 Age: 15 Posts: 3,858 Rep Power: 8	Re: C'mon, c'mon jamal, warning. Harsh critique is NOT allowed under any circumstance; even if the person does ask for it, don't give it. Harsh critique is considered flaming. your relativly new from what I see, so consider yourself lucky this time. And not so much the next. EDIT: Yeah, you pointed out things wrong. But you did not point out anything good. And that is called harsh critique which is considered... OH~! just read what I said before the edit!

05/04/07, 04:31 AM	#20
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: C'mon, c'mon What if I dont find anything good?

05/04/07, 04:32 AM	#21
darkweilder Twilight Knight Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: iono Age: 19 Posts: 969 Rep Power: 5	Re: C'mon, c'mon ^^ good point, you can't always be nice

05/04/07, 04:35 AM	#22
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: C'mon, c'mon And I hope you dont think I am being a smartass or anything, I am just curious.

05/04/07, 04:36 AM	#23
Frozen Inferno Awakens the Broken Bride Join Date: Jan 2006 Age: 15 Posts: 3,858 Rep Power: 8	Re: C'mon, c'mon Then say it in a nicer way instead of blantly saying it sucks. Then, after saying it in a nicer way instead of saying everything is just bad, tell her how to fix it. You said many problems, and gave only one possible thing for her to work off of: "...Add some more color". That falls under just plain bad critique. Tell what colors could be done. Or, tell a possible way to fix this blurriness problem. Tell her how to blend. Now, go read that thread CME posted religiously. Don't post again until you have it memorized, mkay? EDIT: Oh trust me, you surpased my thinking your a smartass. Because if your not trying to be one, its surely how you're coming off.

05/04/07, 04:41 AM	#24
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: C'mon, c'mon Um wow I can't believe I am having an argument with such a narrow thinking point. If I dont say "IMPROVE YOUR BLENDING" but say "the blending is not good" then I am at fault? If I say the blending is not good, that would automatically tell you, that you should work on that aspect.

05/04/07, 04:46 AM	#25
Frozen Inferno Awakens the Broken Bride Join Date: Jan 2006 Age: 15 Posts: 3,858 Rep Power: 8	Re: C'mon, c'mon No, you clearly don't see what i am saying. Give SUGGESTIONS and TIPS on how for someone to do so. Typing it all in caps would be considered just as much flaming as posting something like what you did. What your example was is that basic same thing gets different consiquences. No, they don't. Normally, they would A) Get deleted B) Get a warning or C) Get banned for three days. It would no longer be considered flaming if you would just give tips or suggestions as to how to improve!

05/04/07, 04:49 AM	#26
darkweilder Twilight Knight Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: iono Age: 19 Posts: 969 Rep Power: 5	Re: C'mon, c'mon lol, seriously .... so can you say, "the blending is not good...get better at it, tuts please?" ... good crit? ps. this isn't a discussion on crits btw, this is CME's sig page?

05/04/07, 01:36 PM	#27
Color Me Evil Spy of Atlantis Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Boston Age: 17 Posts: 3,764 Rep Power: 8	Re: C'mon, c'mon Yeah... this turned into a nice little spam topic. Please take all critique to Sparkle's thread. THANKS. [CLOSED]

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode