Sora, Roxas, Ven nobody theory and a bit of BBS too.(Days SPOILERS!)

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 06:50 AM

Well, this is kinda my first time doing a theory but here it goes. I really don't care if you agree with me or not, but I think I might be in the right track... not sure. Also, if someone already posted a theory like this or I placed it in a wrong place or something like that, please feel free to remove or post it in a right place! Thanks! P.s I really don't know how to cover up Spoilers, so please go easy on me if there's a spoiler!

Recently, I been reading the Days manga, played the game and seen BBS trailers and came up with this conclusion:

What if... Roxas wasn't Sora's nobody at all, what if he's Ven's Nobody instead, only his? I mean he has Sora's memories and crap like that, it might be because of the keyblade, he prob got the memories passed down from the keyblade, like the soul of the bearer that wielded it before still lives in it and maybe that's why his memories aren't as vivid as the other organization members. And!

SPOILER!

Spoilers – …

End Spoiler

. And I know, "Then why isn't Ven's memories in it too?" I was watching that trailer where Ven says, "Erase me." Do they apply that it means, "kill"? I was thinking, it could mean, erasing his memory. And in the Days Manga and (maybe?) in the game it's self, doesn't Roxas correct Xemnas,after he leaves, in the dark beach place (don't really know the name, forgot.) "No, My name is...." He could be saying he's Ven's nobody and that Xemnas mistaken him for Sora's, but because of the memory erasing thing, he can't remember? I know that the manga is entirely different from the game, but it could be a clue.

But anyways, that's all my theory. Feel free to argue or agree, but please don't flame, it's my first theory! Thank you for you're cooperation!

-MLA18 :love:

P.S

Sora never let's go of that keyblade IN THE WHOLE GAME (KH2)

So my theory is kinda plausible if you think of the keyblade staying with Sora at all times...

But you know w.e.

I also wanna say, PLEASE READ THE THEORY SLOWLY AND CAREFULLY! Some of the things you're asking about, I wrote in plain English in the theory.

Thank you! :)

Lenexa · November 14th, 2009, 07:59 AM

Are you saying Vens nobody got transferred into sora?

Beyer · November 14th, 2009, 08:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lenexa

Are you saying Vens nobody got transferred into sora?

If by that you mean Roxas fusing with Sora in KH2 then yeah, it doesn't make sense if the theory was true.

@TS: Sorry to say but because of the above reason then no, I don't believe it but I am just one person.
also, PLEASE shrink you sig ASAP! It is pretty cool but insanely big and annoying.

peachie · November 14th, 2009, 09:20 AM

It's been confirmed in the games and by Nomura, that Roxas is Sora's Nobody. This is cold, solid fact. Sorry to say it's not open for debate.

Spoilers

Well...

Spoilers

Quote:

"No, My name is...." He could be saying he's Ven's nobody and that Xemnas mistaken him for Sora's, but because of the memory erasing thing, he can't remember?

Well, Roxas should be confused here. Roxas' name isn't Sora, it's Roxas.

Candylanger · November 14th, 2009, 11:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moonlight_Aqua18

What if... Roxas wasn't Sora's nobody at all, what if he's Ven's Nobody instead, only his?

No, Roxas IS Soras nobody, we don't know yet why he look like Ven, and besides, heartless didn't exist in BBS.

Quote:

Spoilers – …

Spoilers

Quote:

And I know, "Then why isn't Ven's memories in it too?" I was watching that trailer where Ven says, "Erase me." Do they apply that it means, "kill"? I was thinking, it could mean, erasing his memory. And in the Days Manga and (maybe?) in the game it's self, doesn't Roxas correct Xemnas,after he leaves, in the dark beach place (don't really know the name, forgot.) "No, My name is...." He could be saying he's Ven's nobody and that Xemnas mistaken him for Sora's, but because of the memory erasing thing, he can't remember? I know that the manga is entirely different from the game, but it could be a clue.

Xemnas was asking him what his true name was, and since Roxas didn't have any memories of Sora because of Soras short time as Heartless, Roxas couldn't say what his true name was.

D∆NTE · November 14th, 2009, 12:07 PM

[spoil ers] type whatever youre saying here [/spoilers]

How to use spoiler tags^^^.

remember, no spaces.

DarkSoldier85 · November 14th, 2009, 05:15 PM

If Ven's heart were put in Sora and transferred to Roxas, then the heart would affect Roxas' appearance as can be seen with XH changing to a more suitable appearance after possessing Riku.

αsiя · November 14th, 2009, 08:02 PM

Roxas is Sora's nobody
i think it's just pointless to find out that Roxas is actually Ven's nobody because for almost 4 years we've been told that Roxa is Sora's nobody

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 08:10 PM

Okay... I don't think anyone understood me quite perfectly.

I know what happened to Xion, what I mean is that she ALSO went inside the keyblade.

and also, read what I wrote, that possible he doesn't know he's Ven's nobody.

And I also said that IT'S POSSIBLE that he could not be Sora's Nobody... how r we sure? Just because Sora turned into a heartless...? There are a million possibilities how this game can go and how it can end.

But who knows? We just have to wait and see...

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 08:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DarkSoldier85

If Ven's heart were put in Sora and transferred to Roxas, then the heart would affect Roxas' appearance as can be seen with XH changing to a more suitable appearance after possessing Riku.

I been thinking about that theory that when Ven asked to be erased and he meant to go inside to Sora or something like that, seems plausible but really we just have to wait and see...

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 08:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by terra99032

Spoilers

How to use spoiler tags^^^.

remember, no spaces.

Thanks! :) I'll keep that in mind!

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Candylanger

No, Roxas IS Soras nobody, we don't know yet why he look like Ven, and besides, heartless didn't exist in BBS.

Heartless did exist... they just weren't discovered yet. They weren't manipulated yet to do evil, they were just pure darkness sitting there... growing.

Spoilers

I meant that she was BOTH sucked back to Sora and a her memories inside the keyblade. Read what I wrote carefully.

Xemnas was asking him what his true name was, and since Roxas didn't have any memories of Sora because of Soras short time as Heartless, Roxas couldn't say what his true name was.

But he could've also not said Sora... you never know what's really going on in his head in the game, its not like the anime where we hear their inner monologue.

Moonlight_Aqua18 · November 14th, 2009, 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beyer

If by that you mean Roxas fusing with Sora in KH2 then yeah, it doesn't make sense if the theory was true.

@TS: Sorry to say but because of the above reason then no, I don't believe it but I am just one person.
also, PLEASE shrink you sig ASAP! It is pretty cool but insanely big and annoying.

I know that Roxas was sucked back into Sora... I meant that If Roxas wasn't Sora's Nobody but Ven's...

It's fine! Nobody has to agree with me! :)

about the Sig... :cry: I DON"T KNOW HOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Chaosmax · November 14th, 2009, 08:20 PM

No way Roxas is Ven's nobody because of the facts we already know:
1. Heartless didn't exist till after BBS
2. Nomura already stated that Roxas was Sora's nobody
3. There is a connection between Roxas and Ven but he's not Ventus's nobody

But I do have to say u put up a pretty good arguement about this

Allister Rose · November 14th, 2009, 08:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moonlight_Aqua18

I know that Roxas was sucked back into Sora... I meant that If Roxas wasn't Sora's Nobody but Ven's...

It's fine! Nobody has to agree with me! :)

about the Sig... :cry: I DON"T KNOW HOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

roxas was confirmed sora's nobody.

his name is an anagram. is SORA + X = ROXAS>

i doubt ven has a nobody he owuld have to be the first heartless to. which the first heartless was created in ansem the wise's lab.

358/2 days hints the connection to ven and roxas and sora is by "memory" not body and soul