Expanded Version of Unbirth Theory

[keybladelegacy]

Originally Posted by Memory Master

Ven may have lost his memories of MX, it does'nt mean he lost memories of everything else at that point in the game

RR, I have already gone into Riku Replica and I am just about sick of saying this. Namine crushed his memories but Riku Replica himself said, "All I have left are memories of Sora and Namine." He still had some memories left in his heart even if they were fake they were still memories. So no.

Xehanort is the only person who has come close to loosing all his memories. The only thing that kept him from becoming an unbirth was the memory of the name "Xehanort." That one memory kept him from becoming an unbirth.

If i remember correctly Marluxia said that when you lose all your memories that your heart collapse. Then he told Namine to collapse sora's heart so he could rebuild sora or something.

Originally Posted by 3-D

...alright, i just dont believe Ven lost all of his memories

No RR doesn't count, i brought that up on the first page

I think its possible.

Originally Posted by 3-D

i agree with this, and MX said you haven't lost it all yet

He said your losing it but you havent lost it permantely.

[Memory Master]

Originally Posted by keybladelegacy

If i remember correctly Marluxia said that when you lose all your memories that your heart collapse. Then he told Namine to collapse sora's heart so he could rebuild sora or something.


I think its possible.


He said your losing it but you havent lost it permantely.

Marluxia said Sora would end up like the Replica. "You ignorant fool. If Namine erases your memory you'll be a lifeless shell just like Vexen's pathetic replica."

Yet as we saw only seconds after Marluxia said that, the replica attacked Riku. His heart had not collapsed and then Repliku said he still had his memories of Sora and Namine.

Marluxia assumed Namine could erase memories, yet Namine says later that she cannot destroy memories.

Marluxia was dead wrong about memories, Repliku, and Namine so he is not a very trust worthy source for information on memories.
-----------------------------------------------------------

The point remains that the result of what happens when one looses all memories is still shrouded in mystery. My theory suggest that the result of loosing all memory is unbirths.

So my theory cannot be disproved.

[3-D]

erase=destroy?

[Memory Master]

Originally Posted by 3-D

erase=destroy?

Erase=Destroy but Marluxia was wrong about so many things regarding memories so he is not a reliable source of information.

[3-D]

i guess, but i wouldn't be surprised if he was right

[Chrono Mizaki]

Pointing out, but Marluxia can't always be right. After all, he was a newbie to the Organization who suddenly got too big for his own boots and wanted to end up taking control. I wouldn't be surprised if he quickly assume Namine's powers since he thinks of her as a Key to his success.

Yes, we did see him say those exact words. But no one can always be right. It could be a mistake on his behalf, overestimating her powers.