xion who is she and what is shion?

captzakksparrow · August 11th, 2008, 05:26 PM

xion or shion (i dont get the wole shion thing cause dont all org. members have x's in there names) could she possibly be kairi's nobody. now hold on a sec and keep reading yes I know namine is kairis but namine is also a liar, and didnt diz cal her a witch. I bet namine isnt even kairis nobody and xion is. thats why riku recognized her and why she has the keyblade.

Smile · August 11th, 2008, 05:30 PM

Namine isn't a liar. If she were she never would've been so hell bent on telling Sora the truth and setting things straight, but rather either would've gone along with the Organization all along or made up some more complex plot to make Sora forget everything in Castle Oblivion after he took Marluxia out, and the two of them would've lived there happily ever after.
Also, Namine wasn't the one that said she was Kairi's Nobody, but more had everyone around her tell her that. If she's lying about that then it's because the Organization and DiZ lied when they told her about it.
The reason she's called a witch is because Larxene is a bitter sadist and DiZ is a bitter old man that hates everything that was touched by the Organization, thus they call her that. Really going by her being a witch, Larxene would be no less fitting for that title, or even the PoHs, seeing how the "witch" title, if not granted from grudges, was granted to show she even has Powers at all.

What I love about this would be theory is that you're saying Namine isn't Kairi's Nobody, and while I would adore that it must be accompanied with an explanation as to what she yes is - something I doubt you have.
Namine is Kairi's Nobody born of Sora's Body and Soul, with the Sense of Self from Kairi's Heart. Kairi's Body and Soul never had anything bad done to them unless they all lied to us all the the time which makes me think that if there're three Kairis, then where's the third Sora (lol Ven).
Bottom line - Kairi never even managed to create Namine without Sora's help, when would she have had the opportunity to make Xion - assuming of course Xion is really a Nobody, something which has a 50-50 chance of happening. That's the lowest chance of an Organization member being a yes Nobody we've seen.

Colours · August 11th, 2008, 05:34 PM

So far as I know, shion is a name that Namine calls her, but she has to be between the relations of Roxas and Namine.

Raz · August 11th, 2008, 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by captzakksparrow

xion or shion (i dont get the wole shion thing cause dont all org. members have x's in there names) could she possibly be kairi's nobody. now hold on a sec and keep reading yes I know namine is kairis but namine is also a liar, and didnt diz cal her a witch. I bet namine isnt even kairis nobody and xion is. thats why riku recognized her and why she has the keyblade.

She's called a witch because she has the ability to mess with people's memories. Not because she's a mean liar.

Izayoi · August 11th, 2008, 05:35 PM

Because this needs to be said here, even though it is painfully obvious and goes without saying, Xion and Shion are both the same person; the 14th member. The differrence in spelling is becasue of the different translations.

Smile · August 11th, 2008, 05:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elegant Chant

but she has to be between the relations of Roxas and Namine.

No she doesn't, that's mere speculations.

iloveytigers · August 11th, 2008, 05:42 PM

wouldn't it be interesting if Namine was actually one of the few remaining unbirths who's special ability was to mess with your mind, that could bring a whole new way of fighting the enemies in bbs.

Colours · August 11th, 2008, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SufferingAngel

No she doesn't, that's mere speculations.

Lmao, anyways, she came from sora in some way.
Not appearing in KHII, No.14 of Organization XIII, "Shion". As for Naminé knowing her, is it because she interferes with Sora's memory? Or is it something else?

Naminé: "I wanted to meet you."
Naminé: "Shion―――"
・Scene2 Memories of Naminé knowing Shion?
If Sora's memory is not restored completely, surely "she" can't endure it――― In front of the pod Sora sleeps in, Naminé predicts Shion's future. Does DiZ say the word "she" with some doubt?

The destiny awaiting Shion.

Naminé: "Surely she can't endure it."
Naminé: "Not all of the memories have returned."

Smile · August 11th, 2008, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iloveytigers

wouldn't it be interesting if Namine was actually one of the few remaining unbirths who's special ability was to mess with your mind, that could bring a whole new way of fighting the enemies in bbs.

"Remaining"? It's been confirmed she was created when Roxas was. Unless she's a new Unbirth that's highly unlikely, though would explain why she's an exception even amongst exception-Nobodies

iloveytigers · August 11th, 2008, 05:47 PM

maybe unbirths are created from peoples memories. Heart is the heartless. Body and Soul is Nobody. And maybe memory is unbirth.

Smile · August 11th, 2008, 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elegant Chant

Lmao, anyways, she came from sora in some way.
Not appearing in KHII, No.14 of Organization XIII, "Shion". As for Naminé knowing her, is it because she interferes with Sora's memory? Or is it something else?

Naminé: "I wanted to meet you."
Naminé: "Shion―――"
・Scene2 Memories of Naminé knowing Shion?
If Sora's memory is not restored completely, surely "she" can't endure it――― In front of the pod Sora sleeps in, Naminé predicts Shion's future. Does DiZ say the word "she" with some doubt?

The destiny awaiting Shion.

Naminé: "Surely she can't endure it."
Naminé: "Not all of the memories have returned."

I say Shion has Memory powers like Namine, only much more powerful and not restricted just to Sora. She found Roxas interesting and started playing with Sora through him. She got the Keyblade by stealing Sora's Memories and those're the Memories Namine says are missing.
The "she" that can't endure it is Kairi, actually, seeing how Xion also stole Memories of her and have shaped herself in her image - making her look younger and a bit like Kairi in face. Alternatively, Xion didn't steal the Memory perfectly, thus she can't endure it; she messed up.
That's why Riku said her Keyblade up to Shion herself was fake - it was based on someone else's Memories, and not whole Memories at that.
Namine wanted to meet Shion because Shion is much like her one who only peeks into Memories of others and is bound to disappear once Xemnas was through with her. She's a rerun of what the Organization wanted to do with Namine.

Viola. Connection to Sora but not in the way you thought. Feel free to try and tear this apart.

lycorismoon29 · August 11th, 2008, 05:51 PM

Maybe Shion/Xion is an Unbirth! -gasp-

But we barely know what Unbirths are and what the requirement is for creating one, so we can't speculate somebody is something with no definition.

I think Shion/Xion is just the memories of Sora personified in the image of Kairi or something like her or something just like her.(And can't be Aqua because that is a massive chest reduction)

But I'm not gonna speculate on her just because she's a strange character that can be anybody.

Edit: Wait...She's DBABHGTIITOBMOMNBAN.

Colours · August 11th, 2008, 05:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SufferingAngel

I say Shion has Memory powers like Namine, only much more powerful and not restricted just to Sora. She found Roxas interesting and started playing with Sora through him. She got the Keyblade by stealing Sora's Memories and those're the Memories Namine says are missing.
The "she" that can't endure it is Kairi, actually, seeing how Xion also stole Memories of her and have shaped herself in her image - making her look younger and a bit like Kairi in face. Alternatively, Xion didn't steal the Memory perfectly, thus she can't endure it; she messed up.
That's why Riku said her Keyblade up to Shion herself was fake - it was based on someone else's Memories, and not whole Memories at that.
Namine wanted to meet Shion because Shion is much like her one who only peeks into Memories of others and is bound to disappear once Xemnas was through with her. She's a rerun of what the Organization wanted to do with Namine.

Viola. Connection to Sora but not in the way you thought. Feel free to try and tear this apart.

When I state a point, I don't change it, so what you had said is inrevelant, feel free to quote me back.Lmao

Danica Syer · August 11th, 2008, 05:52 PM

Well considering SA and some others answered your question. I will say that Namine isn't a liar just because she's a special nobody--you know considering she's a witch--a good one at that. And not to mention...Xion/Shion...the name...is because of the translation and all that such...I think there another thread that had that answered though. XD

Smile · August 11th, 2008, 05:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elegant Chant

When I state a point, I don't change it, so what you had said is inrevelant, feel free to quote me back.Lmao

What you stated wasn't a point, and what you just said is you being close minded XD; so there, I quoted, all hail Namine the good Witch, lol. :3

Though the more I think about this made-up theory, the more I like it XD