Who are you Xion?

[Anima Relic]

Mmkay, if anyone made a thread exactly like this, I'm sorry, since I'm not on this site is much as I used to be. Now, let's begin.

According to Riku, Xion may be a nobody. Giving her a 50% chance of actually being one.
As most of us know, nobodies that retain their human forms are recruited by the Organization, and they base their personalities off of their memories. They only have a soul and body as well. So if Xion had a heart, then obviously she's not a nobody, but how can anyone know for sure?

Xion has a keyblade, which Riku said it must be a fake, and that leads me to see if my and many others theories about keyblades not having keychains are fake/artificial. So once we actually see Xion's keyblade if it has no keychain, then we'll either know for sure that keyblades without keychains are artificial/fake or that there is another unsolved mystery. Besides that, how would Riku know if a keyblade was fake or not? The only reason I could come up with was the heart unlocker keyblade that had no keychain.

Lastly,Xion wants out of the Organization, since Axel says to her "no matter how many times you escape, I will bring you back" This leads me to believe that the 14th doesn't influence Roxas directly to leave the organization, but she does it indirectly by trying to escape herself from the Organization, especially since we haven't heard anything about them two talking yet. Though, this may not be the case.

[tazztig]

Firsly Xion is neither a nobody or Heartless.
Secondly, riku tells Xion not to interfeer with sora memories, so that could give a clue to tell that she's either a memory from birth, or non-existing.

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by tazztig

Firsly Xion is neither a nobody or Heartless.

I agree for heartless, but it stays to be demonstrated that she is not a nobody.

[Artistry of Schedius]

has it been confirmed that she isnt a nobody or a heartless ormaybe she's just a wandering/missing memory?

riku might have thought it was fake coz:
it might not have a keychain/it is an artificial keyblade or he thinks that only Sora could wield the KK. So riku might have thought that she made a copy of it.

[Yannis]

I think that Xion is the opposite for Namine if you know what I mean.. Namine seems pure and such and Xion is kinda dark version of Namine.. Just a thought..

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

I agree for heartless, but it stays to be demonstrated that she is not a nobody.

A nobody couldn't use a keyblade unless they were the keyblader nobody.
Ex: Roxas used the keyblade because he was sora's nobody.
Xion may have the keyblade because she was either a loss memory awaking from sora, like I said riku said don't interfeer with sora memory's, so she must have been been messing around with them too.>>

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by tazztig

A nobody couldn't use a keyblade unless they were the keyblader nobody.
Ex: Roxas used the keyblade because he was sora's nobody.
Xion may have the keyblade because she was either a loss memory awaking from sora, like I said riku said don't interfeer with sora memory's, so she must have been been messing around with them too.>>

What if she's Aqua's Nobody? Aqua was a Keyblader.

[SuperNova]

Originally Posted by Yannis

I think that Xion is the opposite for Namine if you know what I mean.. Namine seems pure and such and Xion is kinda dark version of Namine.. Just a thought..

I like your idea.
She may be a dark version.

Lastly,Xion wants out of the Organization, since Axel says to her "no matter how many times you escape, I will bring you back" This leads me to believe that the 14th doesn't influence Roxas directly to leave the organization, but she does it indirectly by trying to escape herself from the Organization, especially since we haven't heard anything about them two talking yet.

Yeah,that could be it.
She may be the reason Roxas leaves the Organization.
After seeing her attempts on leaving,the thought of leaving came to his mind and so,he left.
Maybe because he understood that the Organization was bad and it would be wrong to say in there any longer and Xion is a good character who tried to help Roxas by making him understand that the Organization is bad.

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

What if she's Aqua's Nobody? Aqua was a Keyblader.

I was thinking that, but her name doesn't match Aqua's, it would have been Xaqua or Aquxa or something, but somewhere in the stciky's it says that Xion is connected with kairi and namime in some way, meaning if naime was born through kairi and sora, and roxas was born the same way, then that would tell us that she's a loss subject to sora's memory's.>>

[SufferingAngel]

I love correcting this.
Riku didn't say Xion was a Nobody or not.
When she confronted him about lying to her, he said that maybe he didn't exist.

Right now it would seem like she's a messed up mingle of Memories from Sora and Ven.

[Anima Relic]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

What if she's Aqua's Nobody? Aqua was a Keyblader.

Well, if Xion was following the tradition of the Organization as in having added an X to the original name, then I don't beleive for a second that she's Aqua's nobody. Besides that, Xemnas had Aqua's armor and keyblade in the Room of Sleep. I don't believe Xion is a nobody at all, but until I completely know what an Unbirth is, I won't say that she's an Unbirth that retained it's human form, even though I want to say it so badly lol.

@SA

I know that, but it was still implied, he still thought that, even though the translation was different. He said "maybe he didn't exist", which means he thought Xion was a nobody.

Also, I don't see what Ven has to do with this. Sora is involved in some way, but it's way too early to try and throw Ven up in the mix.

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by tazztig

I was thinking that, but her name doesn't match Aqua's, it would have been Xaqua or Aquxa or something, but somewhere in the stciky's it says that Xion is connected with kairi and namime in some way, meaning if naime was born through kairi and sora, and roxas was born the same way, then that would tell us that she's a loss subject to sora's memory's.>>

Well, Xemnas doesn't match Xehanort... And yet Xemnas is Xehanort's Nobody, who took an alias, it's to say Ansem. Why wouldn't Aqua have done the same...?
As for the connection, Aqua is connected to Kairi, and by extension to Namine, so if Xion = Aqua's nobody, Xion is indeed connected to Kairi and Namine...

Originally Posted by Anima Relic

Well, if Xion was following the tradition of the Organization as in having added an X to the original name, then I don't beleive for a second that she's Aqua's nobody. Besides that, Xemnas had Aqua's armor and keyblade in the Room of Sleep. I don't believe Xion is a nobody at all, but until I completely know what an Unbirth is, I won't say that she's an Unbirth that retained it's human form, even though I want to say it so badly lol.

Like I said before, she could have taken an alias... And the armor being there doesn't mean Aqua herself wasn't somewhere else.

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by SufferingAngel

I love correcting this.
Riku didn't say Xion was a Nobody or not.
When she confronted him about lying to her, he said that maybe he didn't exist.

Right now it would seem like she's a messed up mingle of Memories from Sora and Ven.

That is what I've been saying the whole time, she has to be a loss memory or subject to sora because riku said dont mess with sora's sleep or memory>>.Xd

@Lezard Valet,\
Xemnas took on AtW name because he stole his Idenity that is why AtW was hiding.>>

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by tazztig

Xemnas took on AtW name because he stole his Idenity that is why AtW was hiding.>>

Indeed, but why could Xehanort takes someone else identity, and not Aqua...?

[Zero Sora]

A nobody couldn't use a keyblade unless they were the keyblader nobody.

You're forgetting that Riku said her Keyblade was fake. Which means if it's fake, she can wield it regardless if she is a Nobody.