Who are you Xion?

[SufferingAngel]

Originally Posted by Anima Relic

@SA

I know that, but it was still implied, he still thought that, even though the translation was different. He said "maybe he didn't exist", which means he thought Xion was a nobody.

If you read it like you did Xion is also a boy.
Riku said about himself - "Maybe I am the one that doesn't exist.
Check the sticky threads, it's there. The lack of existence implied here, oddly enough, is for Riku, not Xion.

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

Indeed, but why could Xehanort takes someone else identity, and not Aqua...?

It wasn't Xeharont, it was his nobody that stole it, Xehanort turned into a heartless in kh1 or before, but remember when sora confronted xemnas in hollow bastion he said
Sora: Ansem
Xemnas: How long has it been since I abandon that name.
So yes it was xemnas

@Zero Sora
Bah, remember as I said riku asked her, " Why do you have the keyblade, it must be fake". Xion said "don't lie".

[Anima Relic]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

Well, Xemnas doesn't match Xehanort... And yet Xemnas is Xehanort's Nobody, who took an alias, it's to say Ansem. Why wouldn't Aqua have done the same...?
As for the connection, Aqua is connected to Kairi, and by extension to Namine, so if Xion = Aqua's nobody, Xion is indeed connected to Kairi and Namine...



Like I said before, she could have taken an alias... And the armor being there doesn't mean Aqua herself wasn't somewhere else.

True, she could have taken an alias, but if Xion wasn't a nobody, then it'd be pointless.

[SufferingAngel]

Originally Posted by tazztig

It wasn't Xeharont, it was his nobody that stole it, Xehanort turned into a heartless in kh1 or before

Xehanort's Somebody stole Ansem's identity because AtW refused to let his apprentices - led by Xehanort - continue their research on Darkness. They sealed him away, continued their experiments, and then became Nobodies along the way.

Originally Posted by Anima Relic

True, she could have taken an alias, but if Xion wasn't a nobody, then it'd be pointless.

I disagree. An alias is to cover up whom she was to whom she is. Her being a Nobody or not holds little weight as to using an alias or not, imo.

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by tazztig

It wasn't Xeharont, it was his nobody that stole it, Xehanort turned into a heartless in kh1 or before, but remember when sora confronted xemnas in hollow bastion he said
Sora: Ansem
Xemnas: How long has it been since I abandon that name.
So yes it was xemnas

I don't see your point. Xehanort as a whole person stole Ansem's name, proved by the Other Ansem reports when AtW said that his apprentice Xehanort wrote the "Ansem's Report", also Xehanort's Heartless is named Ansem.
Also, I don't see why it stops Aqua to herself having taken an alias.

True, she could have taken an alias, but if Xion wasn't a nobody, then it'd be pointless.

A name is what you use to define yourself. If Aqua saw horrible things, consider she has been unable to help or did something she shouldn't have, etc etc, her name is something that reminds her what she did and was, but it doesn't define her any more, thus she takes a new name, a new identity because she refuses to remain the Aqua who saw or did what she consider is not her any more.
That she be Nobody or not, this logic can apply.

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by Anima Relic

True, she could have taken an alias, but if Xion wasn't a nobody, then it'd be pointless.

Then it's the same as why Xion didn't stay in the organization, she either had to go back into sora like roxas did, maybe that is why roxas had to leave, because she knew roxas couldn' live without sora, and riku even said it while roxas and him was fighting.
Riku: You really are his nobody.
Roxas: I'm me, and only me".
Everyone is making a valid point so far keep going.>>

[Anima Relic]

Originally Posted by SufferingAngel

If you read it like you did Xion is also a boy.
Riku said about himself - "Maybe I am the one that doesn't exist.
Check the sticky threads, it's there. The lack of existence implied here, oddly enough, is for Riku, not Xion.

You misunderstand me, Riku said to himself "Maybe I'M the one that doesn't exist", meaning he indirectly questioned if Xion was a nobody or not, that was what was implied.

[SufferingAngel]

Originally Posted by Anima Relic

You misunderstand me, Riku said to himself "Maybe I'M the one that doesn't exist", meaning he indirectly questioned if Xion was a nobody or not, that was what was implied.

Yeah I thought I was having a double discussion with someone here. I answered in the other thread but will reanswer here - I don't think he was questioning her existence seeing how she's a Member of the Organization. Throw in the fake Keyblade and it further lowers the doubts.
Then the whole issue of being deceived is brought up and seeing Riku's past and how he deals with it all in KH2, it's not hard to imagine how they got from her accusing him of lying to him going into an angst fit.

[logozgogo]

Originally Posted by tazztig

I was thinking that, but her name doesn't match Aqua's, it would have been Xaqua or Aquxa or something, but somewhere in the stciky's it says that Xion is connected with kairi and namime in some way, meaning if naime was born through kairi and sora, and roxas was born the same way, then that would tell us that she's a loss subject to sora's memory's.>>

but u know wat xion without the x is ION which means water. so does aqua. aqua could have made a code name so she could find out wat the organization is doin. because some other theory is xehanort is terra so she is tryin 2 find terra`s nobody.plus namine doesn`t match kairi`s name at all. So ya.

[EdenTheSheep]

Maybe Xion has something to do with the Org? Since everytime she tries to leave Axel keeps bringing her back? And maybe what if she is a nobody then whos? The name of a Org member is normally an anagram with the letter X inserted, so who is Ion? Nio? Oni? Ino? But since the keyblade is fake she might be related to a keyblader. And she might not even be a nobody she could just have something to do with the Org thats why, maybe Xemnas keeps sending Axel to recover her and bring her back.

[trixchasin]

maybe xion is actually an experiment gone bad by vexen,
when he tried to take the rock pokemon: Onix
and spliced its genes with Aqua who is
secretly Kairi (w/a new hair cut) who traveled back in time
to make sure terra never became xehanort.
but was unsuccessful because she died
from losing the will to live
soon after giving birth to her twin boys
sora and riku, whom she had with
terra, who was seduced by the dark side of the force
and joined MX as his new apprentice,
only to lose in a keyblade duel against
ven inside a volcano which then
errupted and spat him out ,
causing him to land in radiant garden
with no memory of it all,
including his arms and legs missing and
his body burnt, resulting in him
having to rely on wearing auto-mail
for the rest of his life, until
he decides to become a state-alchemist
and begins a journey in search of
the philosopher's stone
so that he can get his original body back.
on his journey he faces against homunclulus
*cough* nobodies who are also searching for
the philosopher's stone so that they can be
complete humans again,
unfortunately no one will
ever get the stone because after hairy potter
fight's voldermort in the first harry potter movie,
dumbledore has the stone destroyed. :?

PS. i'm just kidding, i don't honestly think this :-P
don't take it so serious

[Artistry of Schedius]

^you do know thats not possible?

anyway...
@ logozgogo: Namine's name is nowhere near kairi's is probably because she is a speacial nobody.she doesnt have a X coz she inst part of the orgy.

[Rufus Shinra]

Originally Posted by trixchasin

maybe xion is actually an experiment gone bad by vexen,
when he tried to take the rock pokemon: Onix
and spliced its genes with Aqua who is
secretly Kairi (w/a new hair cut) who traveled back in time
to make sure terra never became xehanort.
but was unsuccessful because she died
from losing the will to live
soon after giving birth to her twin boys
sora and riku, whom she had with
terra, who was seduced by the dark side of the force
and joined MX as his new apprentice,
only to lose in a keyblade duel against
ven inside a volcano which then
errupted and spat him out ,
causing him to land in radiant garden
with no memory of it all,
including his arms and legs missing and
his body burnt, resulting in him
having to rely on wearing auto-mail
for the rest of his life, until
he decides to become a state-alchemist
and begins a journey in search of
the philosopher's stone
so that he can get his original body back.
on his journey he faces against homunclulus
*cough* nobodies who are also searching for
the philosopher's stone so that they can be
complete humans again,
unfortunately no one will
ever get the stone because after hairy potter
fight's voldermort in the first harry potter movie,
dumbledore has the stone destroyed. :?

I think there's here at least three impossible cross over here (Harry Potter, Star Wars and Valkyrie Profile), so not really possible.

Btw, congrats for the Premium (X_Roxas_XD !

[trixchasin]

Originally Posted by Lezard Valeth

I think there's here at least three impossible cross over here (Harry Potter, Star Wars and Valkyrie Profile), so not really possible.

never played valk profile,
but u got the other right so far.
the whole list is:
pokemon,
star wars,
fullmetal alchemist
and harry potter lol

[tazztig]

Originally Posted by trixchasin

maybe xion is actually an experiment gone bad by vexen,
when he tried to take the rock pokemon: Onix
and spliced its genes with Aqua who is
secretly Kairi (w/a new hair cut) who traveled back in time
to make sure terra never became xehanort.
but was unsuccessful because she died
from losing the will to live
soon after giving birth to her twin boys
sora and riku, whom she had with
terra, who was seduced by the dark side of the force
and joined MX as his new apprentice,
only to lose in a keyblade duel against
ven inside a volcano which then
errupted and spat him out ,
causing him to land in radiant garden
with no memory of it all,
including his arms and legs missing and
his body burnt, resulting in him
having to rely on wearing auto-mail
for the rest of his life, until
he decides to become a state-alchemist
and begins a journey in search of
the philosopher's stone
so that he can get his original body back.
on his journey he faces against homunclulus
*cough* nobodies who are also searching for
the philosopher's stone so that they can be
complete humans again,
unfortunately no one will
ever get the stone because after hairy potter
fight's voldermort in the first harry potter movie,
dumbledore has the stone destroyed. :?

This doesn't make scence at all buddy, and vexen couldn't have the time to do that...........>>>