Roxified Graphics Vs. vade MacuM GFX// Round 3

Anaru · August 2nd, 2006, 02:24 AM

Roxified

vade

5 votes win, 7 = rape. Battle ends on 8/4/06/ 11:59 PM and the winner will be the contestant with the most votes.

No vade or RG members can vote.

VOTE VOTE VOTE!!!

Veritas · August 3rd, 2006, 08:01 PM

No votes so far. This may end in a tie. >_> I'd like to give RG some CnC as I have already told Darkwatch what I thought of his over MSN. I'll give a brief summary of his.

DW/Vade:
- Don't really like text on left.
- Don't like how the h arches out of the sword.
- It has nice blending, and it looks good overall.

Roxified: The render on the left doesn't blend and does nothing to add flow. It looks like you found a C4D and slapped it on. Over his shoulder you can see a line from possibly the edge of an image you added that looks like you tried to blend in by using brushes on top of it. The dot and light pinkish color on the right is extremely random. It needs a light source of some sort. Compared to DW's yours looks extremely sloppy. I'm not trying to be mean. I just thought you'd appreciate some CnC on it.

The Midnight Channel · August 3rd, 2006, 08:03 PM

I've disgraced myself by entering that...

Veritas · August 3rd, 2006, 08:13 PM

I know where you can find some tuts, and I'd be glad to help you get better. I think DW is fine with helping you as well. PM me whenever or contact me on AIM or MSN if you're interested. Sorry for spamming this thread a little.

Black_Star · August 3rd, 2006, 08:15 PM

Okay. I'll vote.

Both tags are pretty monotone. I choose Vade because of the stock. Basically because it has 'life'. The Gaara stock is boring and lifeless. The Gaara tag's upper right doesn't really fit with the rest of it.It also has no light source. The Bleach tag is barely better, but it gets my vote.

Vade

Anaru · August 5th, 2006, 07:51 AM

Well the date has been passed and vade wins by default. So vade wins the whole match 3/0. Good job both sides, you both did well.