SotW #27 - Judging

Banishing Blade · March 18th, 2006, 06:36 PM

All right people, let's see what you think. The fate of the winner is in your hands, now get to work! Remember, if you didn't enter, you can't vote! Good luck everybody.

Note from Raito: As posted below, all judging needs to be completed by 3 PM my time (Eastern Standard) on Sunday the 19th.

Milky · March 18th, 2006, 06:38 PM

1. Darky Dee(http://img226.imageshack.us/img226/5...lldarky6uh.png)
I absolutely love the sig. Great flow. There's nothing much i can really say about it. Its just great.

2.KeyBreaker(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v6...0me/sotw_3.jpg)
Very nice Gandalf/Saruman sig. I like the way you used both stocks. Brushing is awesome. 9.5/10.

3. Ryu(http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b3.../ZackSephi.png)
VERY good for a last minute sig. Heh. I was going around warning people who were entering to finish up because iit was liek 5 minutes before noon. I guess BB needs his beauty sleep. So you had some time. Great sig. Move the stocks a bit more to the left. increase brightness a bit. and it would be good.

Darky Dee · March 18th, 2006, 07:01 PM

Meh, I'll vote later on. I'll wait until BeeBee/Rai/Peekay put all the sigs on one big canvas so I can compare and contrast them. Edit when ready to vote.

//edit: Meh, going to vote anyways. ),:

1) .Oathkeeper:
AWESOME! Traidional and classic Oathy technique, color definately compliments it. Also, seems simple, but VERY effective with only one additional stock. <3

2) Ryu:
I told you on AIM that I would love to *rabe* it. Very nice, numerous ammount of stocks is amazing. Coloration and blending is very nice. Text, meh, so-so. But still rabable. xD

3) Perminator:
Pretty crisp and clear. Text is much better. MUCHO props to you. ;) Additional stocks is a major plus. Very shmexsay. <3

[[Sidenote:]]
Keybreaker, your sig definately gets major kudos to. I LOVE it as well. Lord of the Rings=Bliss. I like the effect that you made it seem flying off the canvas. :3

Many great sigs this week. Scarecrow, yours was pretty sweet too.

PeeKay, very creative on making your own stock. Original.

Color Me Knievel · March 18th, 2006, 09:28 PM

So do I ^

Will edit with my votes.

Ryu · March 19th, 2006, 05:35 AM

1. .Oathkeeper.

Love the image you used, Sephiroth's picture, the colors, etc. And even though a lot of people tried out your style, you're still the only one who can claim to be a master at it.

2. KeyBreaker

Very nice tag, it could use some improvement, but it's definitely one of the best of this SotW. I like how you used the filmstrip, and I haven't seen a lot of your work, but I do think this is one of your best from all that I have seen.

3. Darky Dee

One of your best up till now. I like how you added the effect to the blood at the right, and even though there's always room for improvement, it deserves a spot in this top 3.

Rich · March 19th, 2006, 01:23 PM

In order to get ready for the next SotW, which I will be in charge of, all judging needs to be completed by 3 PM today my time (Eastern Standard Time). Any votes not given by then will not be counted, sorry.

Color Me Knievel · March 19th, 2006, 01:52 PM

1. Ryu - Love the colors and the design, it has a very nice manga layout, and I like the cool border. Very good job.

2. Darky Dee - Awesome one, I love how you managed to fit so many effects without crowding the tag, the blood splatter, text and pictures are fit together very well, in ole' good Darky style.

3. KeyBreaker - What can you say? Awesome idea with Saruman and Gandalf, the filmstrip, and how you captured their personalities.

Very many awesome entries, everyone, all you people surprise me all the time. =D

Oathy · March 19th, 2006, 02:59 PM

Kay, gotta do this fast because I'll be at theatre rehearsal...

1.) Keybreaker--Excellent Saruman and Gandalf sig. You brought me back to my Ringer days...*happy sigh* Love the angle, love the blending, love the colors. Absolutely beautiful.

2.) Darky Dee--Awesome!! Makes me almost want to watch Kill Bill without covering my eyes. xD A bit blocky and linear, but very creative. The filmstrip works well here.

3.) Prodigy Keyblade--I had to do it. Pure mouse-art love.

RYU GETS MY HONORABLE MENTION! AWESOME ZACK/SEPHY SIG!

Rich · March 19th, 2006, 08:04 PM

Judging is officially closed.

This week we have a tie! Our 2 winners are Darky Dee and KeyBreaker! Excellent work to everyone, it was a great week.

Our winners will soon go up on the Wall of Fame, and a new SotW is to come shortly.