AMV Battle: GTX vs. Katana

Katana · November 19th, 2005, 01:20 AM

Yay for amv battles! Please rate the two vids... and vote for your favorite.

GTX:
http://s24.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=1...O1T22VODZYCPHT
Song: "New Disease"
Artist: Spineshank
Clips: Devil May Cry 3 and Resident Evil 4
Length: 3:18
Size: 47.43 mb

Katana:
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=3MLP7N5V
Song: "R-Evolve"
Artist: 30 Seconds to Mars
Clips: Final Fantasy: Advent Children-- A Kadaj Tribute (So beware of the spoilers)
Length: 4:09
Size: 49.3 mb
Note: Had to use megaupload.com, hope that isn't a problem.

---

Whoever has the most votes by the end of the day, sunday, wins... an explanation of your vote is always greatly appreciated.

Choose wisely :D.

sora92120 · November 19th, 2005, 04:53 AM

hmmm my vote goes to GTX. although GTX's video was a bit random when it came to the RE4 clips ad the clips didnt seem to fit as good as the DM3 clips.

Katana, it seemed llike u barely worked on ur video. u just put clips and used transitions from the way i see it. it was good at like 40 seconds of the video but that was it.

Mikail · November 19th, 2005, 03:17 PM

GTX GMV. His just flowed better with clips and song. Nothing else needs to be said.

Isis · November 19th, 2005, 08:47 PM

Holy harshness batman... not to mention completely unreasonable. Both vids = wicked. . but GTX's was little too random... the fighting clips worked awesomely wit the beat, but they were also just kind of...there. I didn't see how they matched the song. It did look like you put a lot of work into it though.

Katana did use sum long clips.. but they worked well that way and I don't know that having long clips means that no work was put into the video. Some might have been a little shorter,but all in all I don't see them as a problem for how "good" the vid was. All the clips used were cool with the music-- There were a few though that didn't match the words completely.

Katanas got my vote.

chaywa · November 19th, 2005, 09:15 PM

Both superb...can't deny thata fact...this is a very close call

I agree with what Isis said about the slight randomness in GTXs, some clips were either slightly short (or slightly out of place with with the beat) but the fighting clips worked well, especially the Intro.

Katana's was equally good...very simple making, but it was effective...mostly fitted the beat apart from the Cloud and Kadaj fight scene in the middle...and yes some were long, but they needed to be mostly...

This is a tough call, both excellent AMVs fitting to the music well...but my vote goes to Kat b/c it wasn't as random...thank god ur not gonna use this in our AMV battle...