Rate

[darren]

hey guys, i just made this new sig, tell me what you think

[laath]

it is pissing me off seeing that EVERYONE on these forums is now making pretty much the SAME exact thing. Stop doing everything like everyone and make your OWN thing. But, anyways,

I do like this. I like the blue color, even though its just like everyone elses. The brush work is also very nice, even though its just like everyone else. The abstractness is cool, even though its like everyone elses. I do overall like this work, but again, its just like everyone elses. One thing wrong though, is the text. It doesn't look very good.

8/10 if it wasn't like everyone elses, but since it is, you get a 7 or 7.5

[darren]

hey atleast i have a sig, and some skill, i just asked what u thought, not how unique it was, im not the best sig maker, and so what if i take ideas from otheres and make something out of it, it takes work, anyone else wanna rate?

[Anti-Dark]

darren it is true, it used to be awesome when there were just a few grunges ou tthere, they do get kind of annoying, its getting harder and harder to get uniqueness in a sig theses days, I'd say this is a........work of average quality

GOODNESS
colors are perfect

BADNESS
technique is average, BG is bleh, quite blurry, text is just plain, I normally don't put text on my grunges, no point really, just a regular border

[darren]

well this is my first grunge, that went well at least

[imperfectgirl13]

~4/5~ meow

[darren]

kay, i took the text out

[SoulEater]

i think its great 9/10

dont pick on Darren, he hasnt been doing this long. i am pulling for ya dude. Keep making stuffs.

[darren]

thanks, finally some encouraging comments

[Anti-Dark]

haha, I am hard on sigs, hehe, oh well, what can you expect from me?

see now it looks plain in that area without text, just fill it in with some other brushing and it'll look better, since you had text there, you didn't plan on having anything to fill it, just fill it in, then post it up

Pretty good 8/10

[KingGabriel_VXI]

Its kinda plain...And yall are rite,im just noticing this but everyone is brushing like that.The brushing is nice but its kinda getting old.I dont really like it even tho its nice,its plain. Its small for me and theres no character in the pic. 7/10

[laath]

lol everything I say here is taken to offense. I said its a GOOD BANNER, which means I like it. I just don't like how it looks like everyone elses. If your implying that I have no skills.... then you're far off. I make graphics too. I just have to get my Photoshop back. I have my 3DSM right now, but I can;t do anything with my renders w/o PS... so... just because I don't have a sig doesn't mean I don't make graphics.

And I would love if you still made stuff. I'm not saying that I want you to be banned from sig making forever or anything. I was just making a comment that it looks like everyone elses, which I'm getting tired of.

And btw, I do like it more w/o the text.

[darren]

wel im sorry for gettin mad, and i didn't mean you had no skills, i just meant even if it is common it still takes some skill, and i didn't know grunges were that unpopular now thats all

[Cloud_Unchained]

Well, It looks like a sig I made, a sig Logpile made, a sig AO made (just without a stock).

It's okay. The colors are very well matching.