[VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae

Silh · 04/14/07, 01:38 AM

You must be a graphics artist that isn't a member of either clan to vote. First to seven votes wins. The entries are as follows:

- Evrae
http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j3...sakuracopy.jpg

- Silh
http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/264/efsto4.png

**Milkman** · 04/14/07, 01:45 AM

Victory to Silh, Well pulled off. Tag has the same mood as the trailer itself, Flow and depth is good. Text is fine too.

Infinity's End · 04/14/07, 03:10 AM

Evrae, although it is a tad bright

Brutal · 04/14/07, 03:18 AM

Can clan members vote? >.<

**Gamergirl89** · 04/14/07, 03:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silh

You must be a graphics artist that isn't a member of either clan to vote.

naw u cant vote ryuuzaki
anywayz silh's gfx ftw
smudging at its best xD

Just as Planned · 04/14/07, 03:57 AM

Silh gets my vote. All I'm seeing in Evrae's is high contrast, brushing, blurring, and soft light. At least his actually has some sense of depth. (even though i've seen better from you) It's really no contest here.

Banishing Blade · 04/14/07, 05:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silh

You must be a graphics artist

... ahem

Anyway. I'm not feeling the grey colour, but it definately suits the stock, considering the mood of the trailer it came from. Smudging is pulled off quite well. Would be nice to see a bit more of the stock's colours in the tag (particularly the hair colour).

From a personal stand point, I don't particularily like either =/ But I'm gonna have to say that Silh's is the better tag.

Evrae's tag seems way too lightened, it ruins the colour choice. The brushes (at least, I'm gonna assume they're brushes) seem random, and don't compliment the stock.

C4E · 04/14/07, 06:06 AM

Current tally
4-1 in silh's favor.

Darky Dee · 04/16/07, 10:24 PM

Silh GMV-- too bright, and the composition is dry IMO, which Silh's is too, but it has more and better techniques used. Silh, your text is VERY bland, and right is empty.

Trigger · 04/26/07, 05:26 PM

Silh gtv , and I wont even bother giving my explanation . . .

**blinkboy211** · 04/26/07, 05:30 PM

Silh has the best one and like trigger i dont have the motivation to explain

Brutal · 04/26/07, 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blinkboy211

Silh has the best one and like trigger i dont have the motivation to explain

Quote:

You must be a graphics artist that isn't a member of either clan to vote.

... ahem.

Trigger · 04/27/07, 03:35 AM

If those are the rules then it is ironic seeing as all of the experienced graphic artists are in my clan =\

~~jamal~~ · 04/27/07, 04:14 AM

Silh gets the vote on this one. I dont particularly fancy either, but Silh's has decent smudging and some nice text. The lighting and stock position is decent as well.

As for the other one I feel it is to chaotic and random, and that there were layers of gaussian blur added, which did not add to the tag.

C4E · 04/29/07, 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Trigger

If those are the rules then it is ironic seeing as all of the experienced graphic artists are in my clan =\

Point taken.
If you guys dont mind in clan voting then I guess we can allow both clans to vote, as long as they are voting for the better tag and not just their own clan member.

So for now I guess ill say victory to 5G3.
if you guys want to try and get more votes thats fine too.

04/14/07, 01:38 AM	#1
Silh But a proud, proud man. Join Date: May 2004 Age: 17 Posts: 2,900 Rep Power: 11	[VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae You must be a graphics artist that isn't a member of either clan to vote. First to seven votes wins. The entries are as follows: - Evrae http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j3...sakuracopy.jpg - Silh http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/264/efsto4.png

04/14/07, 01:45 AM	#2
Milkman I REJECT YOUR REALITY Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada Posts: 3,639 Rep Power: 8	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Victory to Silh, Well pulled off. Tag has the same mood as the trailer itself, Flow and depth is good. Text is fine too.

04/14/07, 03:10 AM	#3
Infinity's End ars gratia artis Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: A place called style. Age: 16 Posts: 1,914 Rep Power: 3	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Evrae, although it is a tad bright

04/14/07, 03:18 AM	#4
Brutal lol sup Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: a ghetto little place in minnesota Age: 16 Posts: 3,429 Rep Power: 8	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Can clan members vote? >.<

04/14/07, 03:57 AM	#6
Just as Planned Organization Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Faggot Barn Posts: 431 Rep Power: 2	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Silh gets my vote. All I'm seeing in Evrae's is high contrast, brushing, blurring, and soft light. At least his actually has some sense of depth. (even though i've seen better from you) It's really no contest here.

04/14/07, 06:06 AM	#8
C4E Procrastination is Key Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: o.o somewhere... Graphics Clan: Divine Comedy Age: 18 Posts: 1,896 Rep Power: 6	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Current tally 4-1 in silh's favor.

04/16/07, 10:24 PM	#9
Darky Dee Tastefully Candid Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Tabloids Age: 21 Posts: 2,438 Rep Power: 7	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Silh GMV-- too bright, and the composition is dry IMO, which Silh's is too, but it has more and better techniques used. Silh, your text is VERY bland, and right is empty.

04/26/07, 05:26 PM	#10
Trigger L E G E N D Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: New York Age: 20 Posts: 1,107 Rep Power: 5	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Silh gtv , and I wont even bother giving my explanation . . .

04/26/07, 05:30 PM	#11
blinkboy211 peace and chicken grease Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: St. Louis Age: 20 Posts: 3,844 Rep Power: 5	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Silh has the best one and like trigger i dont have the motivation to explain

04/27/07, 03:35 AM	#13
Trigger L E G E N D Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: New York Age: 20 Posts: 1,107 Rep Power: 5	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae If those are the rules then it is ironic seeing as all of the experienced graphic artists are in my clan =\

04/27/07, 04:14 AM	#14
~~jamal~~ Banned Join Date: Apr 2007 Age: 18 Posts: 20 Rep Power: 0	Re: [VOTING] 5g³ vs. -D.i.T-, battle one: Silh vs. Evrae Silh gets the vote on this one. I dont particularly fancy either, but Silh's has decent smudging and some nice text. The lighting and stock position is decent as well. As for the other one I feel it is to chaotic and random, and that there were layers of gaussian blur added, which did not add to the tag.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode