(HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa

**mendia** · 11/05/06, 06:21 PM

ROUND TWO

Rules: Tag must have a real life person as a stock. First to 6.

Participants: _Odin_, Chaywa

Entries

_Odin_:

Chaywa:

**chaywa** · 11/05/06, 07:30 PM

Bleh i can't do human stock well...:
My Entry

(In first post.)

_Odin_ · 11/05/06, 07:33 PM

oh, man, i think chaywa is gonna win.

good luck, man.

_Omni_ · 11/05/06, 09:41 PM

Ow........
This one is kinda hard.

Chawya's entry is nice except for a few spots on the right, and the text. Love the lightning source and negative space in this one.

Odin's entry is alot more original. Weird, but original.

However, in terms of eye pleasing, Chaywa GMV.

cloud_leingod · 11/06/06, 01:33 AM

odin: i like the idea of this tag. its very random but it works well. i dont like the bg tho cuz its like a drak cloud, it shud be more colorful to match the stock and the effects.

chaywa: the filters and lighting source r great. text could be better but every thing else looks good.

chaywa gmv.

~Leo~ · 11/06/06, 01:56 AM

[Edited slightly]

Odin gmv.

-The following comments reserve the right to be half-assed-

Your style is different. I love your concepts and such. No exceptions here. However, I feel the right side's slight messyness kinda disrupts the calmness of the right.

Chaywa, not much appeals to me in yours. I dislike the text alot, the C4D's to the left look choppy, and it kinda looks like it's in half b/w, which doesn't look too good IMO. Perhaps some more color?

thisvoteisnotbiased

Color Me Evil · 11/06/06, 02:06 AM

Quote:

Odin's entry is alot more original. Weird, but original.

Why is is weird? Give reasons guys, or else it might be considered bias.

Quote:

i dont like the bg tho.

Same as above. Provide reasons as to why you don't like something and how they can make it better.

Hiei-chan · 11/06/06, 03:18 AM

odin GMV

i love the whole thing, the vector, the vector shapes,the great positioning,
everything screams originallity,

thats why odin GMV

Hanatori · 11/06/06, 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hiei-chan

odin GMV

i love the whole thing, the vector, the vector shapes,the great positioning,
everything screams originallity,

thats why odin GMV

Reasons why you didn't choose the other/critique.

Hiei-chan · 11/07/06, 03:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanatori

Reasons why you didn't choose the other/critique.

seemed kinda empty, just a bunch of c4d laying around =/

the tag is great but i dont find it eye apealing

**mendia** · 11/07/06, 03:49 AM

I'm allowing all votes so far.

2-2, it's tied! Keep it up.

_Odin_ · 11/07/06, 04:01 PM

yay, this is exciting!

come on guys, vote!

Aminity · 11/08/06, 07:07 PM

Odin gmv.

The lighting on Chaywa's tag is to strong. It has flow and all but I'm just not feeling it. Odin's tag needs some depth to it, but aside from that I like it.

Scarecrow · 11/10/06, 04:50 AM

Odin Gmv.

Chaywa's tag is too strong for my liking, and the render seems too sharp. The change between light and dark is also very sudden.

I like Odin's more due to the colours used, and the overall composition. Effects on the left are great, too.

_Odin_ · 11/10/06, 05:17 PM

chaywa: 2
Odin: 4

come on, come on! more votes!

11/05/06, 06:21 PM	#1
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	(HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa ROUND TWO Rules: Tag must have a real life person as a stock. First to 6. Participants: _Odin_, Chaywa Entries _Odin_: Chaywa: Last edited by mendia; 11/12/06 at 11:18 PM.

11/05/06, 07:30 PM	#2
chaywa (E)motion Isn't Meaning Join Date: May 2005 Location: Chamber of Guf Age: 19 Posts: 5,313 Rep Power: 11	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa Bleh i can't do human stock well...: My Entry (In first post.) Last edited by Scarecrow; 11/06/06 at 08:20 AM.

11/05/06, 07:33 PM	#3
_Odin_ O_o Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Where do you want me to be? Age: 15 Posts: 2,339 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa oh, man, i think chaywa is gonna win. good luck, man.

11/05/06, 09:41 PM	#4
_Omni_ .The Rebirth of GFX. Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Don't trust ya' Posts: 1,387 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa Ow........ This one is kinda hard. Chawya's entry is nice except for a few spots on the right, and the text. Love the lightning source and negative space in this one. Odin's entry is alot more original. Weird, but original. However, in terms of eye pleasing, Chaywa GMV.

11/06/06, 01:33 AM	#5
cloud_leingod Twilight Knight Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 910 Rep Power: 3	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa odin: i like the idea of this tag. its very random but it works well. i dont like the bg tho cuz its like a drak cloud, it shud be more colorful to match the stock and the effects. chaywa: the filters and lighting source r great. text could be better but every thing else looks good. chaywa gmv. Last edited by cloud_leingod; 11/06/06 at 03:07 PM.

11/06/06, 01:56 AM	#6
~Leo~ Ruler of Light Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: boo Age: 15 Posts: 648 Rep Power: 3	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa [Edited slightly] Odin gmv. -The following comments reserve the right to be half-assed- Your style is different. I love your concepts and such. No exceptions here. However, I feel the right side's slight messyness kinda disrupts the calmness of the right. Chaywa, not much appeals to me in yours. I dislike the text alot, the C4D's to the left look choppy, and it kinda looks like it's in half b/w, which doesn't look too good IMO. Perhaps some more color? thisvoteisnotbiased Last edited by ~Leo~; 11/06/06 at 03:12 AM.

11/06/06, 03:18 AM	#8
Hiei-chan L O N E L Y Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Sitting next to Eclipse,tr,an doomy trying to get the last donut >.< Age: 17 Posts: 2,046 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa odin GMV i love the whole thing, the vector, the vector shapes,the great positioning, everything screams originallity, thats why odin GMV

11/07/06, 03:49 AM	#11
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa I'm allowing all votes so far. 2-2, it's tied! Keep it up.

11/07/06, 04:01 PM	#12
_Odin_ O_o Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Where do you want me to be? Age: 15 Posts: 2,339 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa yay, this is exciting! come on guys, vote!

11/08/06, 07:07 PM	#13
Aminity R.I.P. Sh[EX] Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Wherever Posts: 2,301 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa Odin gmv. The lighting on Chaywa's tag is to strong. It has flow and all but I'm just not feeling it. Odin's tag needs some depth to it, but aside from that I like it.

11/10/06, 04:50 AM	#14
Scarecrow borderline ↓ Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: :noitacoL Age: 17 Posts: 2,877 Rep Power: 7	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa Odin Gmv. Chaywa's tag is too strong for my liking, and the render seems too sharp. The change between light and dark is also very sudden. I like Odin's more due to the colours used, and the overall composition. Effects on the left are great, too.

11/10/06, 05:17 PM	#15
_Odin_ O_o Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Where do you want me to be? Age: 15 Posts: 2,339 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) _Odin_ vs. Chaywa chaywa: 2 Odin: 4 come on, come on! more votes!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode