(HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. *twilight_riku*

**mendia** · 10/23/06, 12:57 AM

ROUND ONE

Rules: Must have anime character(or characters) as the stock(or stocks).

Participants: mendia, *twilight_riku*

Entries

mendia:

*twilight_riku*:

First to six votes wins. No rape.

***twilight_riku*** · 10/23/06, 01:07 AM

Hiei-chan · 10/30/06, 04:50 PM

Mendy GMV

i like the vector shapes and the smudging in the bg,

the tiny text ias unnessary and it could use some color but still hawt

*TR* is too dark and over contrast =/

thats why mendy GMV

**mendia** · 10/31/06, 01:04 AM

All right, thanks for voting, Hiei!

Now lets keep this going :D

_Omni_ · 10/31/06, 01:10 AM

Mendia GMV

TR's tag is overcontrasted and there's C4D looks just thrown on there. It looks like he/she could've added something.

Mendia's tag just looked better. Can't really tell what's going on, but it's more pleasing to the eyes. And I like the light source.

**Milkman** · 10/31/06, 01:47 AM

Mendia GMV

TR's is too contrasted and lacks a good light source

Mendies has everything TR's doesnt.

**mendia** · 10/31/06, 03:15 AM

3-0

Mendia in the lead.

Keep voting, people!

***twilight_riku*** · 10/31/06, 08:47 AM

cant i just give up i can see where its going already lol ... if i had more time on my hands im sure i could have done better

**mendia** · 10/31/06, 10:02 PM

You can give up if you like but there's still a chance you can come back :/

But if you truly think it will just be a waste of time continuing, go ahead and quit, no one's stopping you :p

***twilight_riku*** · 11/01/06, 10:43 AM

no just let the votes carry on its ok

**Dogenzaka** · 11/02/06, 05:47 PM

mendia ftw.

It seems to fit the mood it wants to display much better, although I'm a bit confused about the flow. The lighting seems off....and I really don't know where it flows. But the whole style and (smudging is it?) chosen behind it is pulled off well. (I wish I knew how to smudge like that...you know get a 3D pulled-off cloud effect xD)

twlight riku:

It's a great tag with great flow, however the text seems to get in the way of the flow, like it's trying to ride on top of it or something, I'd try a different font or position/direction. The tag in itself is a tad dark but I like it. It's a bit boring after a while because all there is are those sparks and then black. Try some more.

mendia gets my vote.

**mendia** · 11/02/06, 06:34 PM

Update.

I lead, 4-0.

_Odin_ · 11/03/06, 11:12 PM

mendia.

much better when it comes to design, compostion, and contrast.

TR's is TOO contrast and really just seems broing (just renders).

mendia.

**mendia** · 11/04/06, 06:06 AM

5-0

Just one more vote and we can get on with the next round.

***twilight_riku*** · 11/04/06, 11:28 AM

i think 5 is enough lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by _Odin_

TR's is TOO contrast and really just seems broing (just renders).

no shiz.

10/23/06, 12:57 AM	#1
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	(HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku ROUND ONE Rules: Must have anime character(or characters) as the stock(or stocks). Participants: mendia, twilight_riku Entries mendia: twilight_riku: First to six votes wins. No rape. Last edited by mendia; 10/31/06 at 12:58 AM.

10/23/06, 01:07 AM	#2
*twilight_riku* /\ Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 3,676 Rep Power: 6	Re: <Healing Vision><Vade Vacum> Round ONE Last edited by twilight_riku; 10/30/06 at 05:05 PM.

10/30/06, 04:50 PM	#3
Hiei-chan L O N E L Y Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Sitting next to Eclipse,tr,an doomy trying to get the last donut >.< Age: 17 Posts: 2,046 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku Mendy GMV i like the vector shapes and the smudging in the bg, the tiny text ias unnessary and it could use some color but still hawt TR is too dark and over contrast =/ thats why mendy GMV

10/31/06, 01:04 AM	#4
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku All right, thanks for voting, Hiei! Now lets keep this going :D

10/31/06, 01:10 AM	#5
_Omni_ .The Rebirth of GFX. Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Don't trust ya' Posts: 1,387 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku Mendia GMV TR's tag is overcontrasted and there's C4D looks just thrown on there. It looks like he/she could've added something. Mendia's tag just looked better. Can't really tell what's going on, but it's more pleasing to the eyes. And I like the light source.

10/31/06, 01:47 AM	#6
Milkman I REJECT YOUR REALITY Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada Posts: 3,639 Rep Power: 8	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku Mendia GMV TR's is too contrasted and lacks a good light source Mendies has everything TR's doesnt.

10/31/06, 03:15 AM	#7
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku 3-0 Mendia in the lead. Keep voting, people!

10/31/06, 08:47 AM	#8
*twilight_riku* /\ Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 3,676 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku cant i just give up i can see where its going already lol ... if i had more time on my hands im sure i could have done better

10/31/06, 10:02 PM	#9
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku You can give up if you like but there's still a chance you can come back :/ But if you truly think it will just be a waste of time continuing, go ahead and quit, no one's stopping you :p

11/01/06, 10:43 AM	#10
*twilight_riku* /\ Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 3,676 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku no just let the votes carry on its ok

11/02/06, 05:47 PM	#11
Dogenzaka PLATINUM USERNAME WINS Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: KEYBUREDO? Graphics Clan: TheCitrusDistrict Age: 17 Posts: 8,689 Rep Power: 14	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku mendia ftw. It seems to fit the mood it wants to display much better, although I'm a bit confused about the flow. The lighting seems off....and I really don't know where it flows. But the whole style and (smudging is it?) chosen behind it is pulled off well. (I wish I knew how to smudge like that...you know get a 3D pulled-off cloud effect xD) twlight riku: It's a great tag with great flow, however the text seems to get in the way of the flow, like it's trying to ride on top of it or something, I'd try a different font or position/direction. The tag in itself is a tad dark but I like it. It's a bit boring after a while because all there is are those sparks and then black. Try some more. mendia gets my vote.

11/02/06, 06:34 PM	#12
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku Update. I lead, 4-0.

11/03/06, 11:12 PM	#13
_Odin_ O_o Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Where do you want me to be? Age: 15 Posts: 2,339 Rep Power: 5	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku mendia. much better when it comes to design, compostion, and contrast. TR's is TOO contrast and really just seems broing (just renders). mendia.

11/04/06, 06:06 AM	#14
mendia Premium member Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 3,157 Rep Power: 6	Re: (HVG vs. FDD) mendia vs. twilight_riku 5-0 Just one more vote and we can get on with the next round.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode