TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip

~~Eclipse~~ · 08/29/06, 01:23 AM

This is my last post. But the clans were bugging about this.

Basically, FDD forfeited one round, TNY fofeited one round, and I believed that we were tied. I thought it was fair, but some members complained how it was unfair Shiro forfeited. I hardly see how it isn't fair, especially considering she asked to forfeit, and it tied us. BUT WHATEVER.

Anywho =]

It's my AMV pitted against Shiro-Chan's

Mine:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9xkzyPW9Cg

Shiro-Chan's:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSiCx5zhhM4

Got it?

You know the rules

first to 6 wins, 0-5 = rape.

Begin!!

Hellpark · 08/29/06, 01:38 AM

My vote is for Eclipse. The other one seems boring and dull because of the music and I lost interest by the middle. Eclipses seems to fit the AMV better and its just more entertaining to me.

**LimitLess** · 08/29/06, 02:12 AM

Eclipse- AMV was pretty good. It flowed nicely. Nice song choice, and your clips went well with the lyrics at times. There were quite a few random clips, but overall good job.

Shiro- Ahhh I don't know if it was your first or not because I haven't seen you make one before, but it was alright. The song was what ruined it. It became dull and just plain. You seem to have the concept of following beat, but it was just boring.

Eclipse GMV

Hiei-chan · 08/29/06, 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hellpark

My vote is for Eclipse. The other one seems boring and dull because of the music and I lost interest by the middle. Eclipses seems to fit the AMV better and its just more entertaining to me.

QOUTE FOR EFFECT

Eclipsy GMV

well even though Shiro-chans was unique an beautiful, it got alittle boring in the begining, eclipsy was more entertaining

Meilin · 08/29/06, 09:24 PM

Agreeing with the others.
Shiro had beat sync down, but I prefer the lyric-sync, so my vote is for

E-CHAN GMV

ansemx18 · 08/30/06, 02:07 AM

I dont think that Nickelback fit the first one and chans was just slow and they both lost my attention. If there are any more of these amv competitions id like to show off mine.

**LimitLess** · 08/30/06, 02:33 AM

Hey buddy you need to vote or not post at all. There are more AMV competitions but we already have our selected few and this is a battle between two clans, which im sure you not into right this moment.

08/30/06, 09:56 AM

Honestly, I didn't really like either of them much.

Eclipse: Didn't interest me. The whole thing seemed a little forced.

Shiro: Albeit a little dull, it was still a beautiful AMV. Loved the part where you kept in the in-game talking.

Shiro GMV

D2L · 09/08/06, 02:29 AM

Eclipse: even thoughyou used a Nickleback song for a KH vid (which in my book is EXTREMELY overrated now) I think it was good.

Shiro: It was just dull, I liked the concept and all just choose a diff. song next time.

Eclipses ftw.

08/29/06, 01:23 AM	#1
~~Eclipse~~ Banned Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: In a crater of love. Age: 17 Posts: 7,585 Rep Power: 0	TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip This is my last post. But the clans were bugging about this. Basically, FDD forfeited one round, TNY fofeited one round, and I believed that we were tied. I thought it was fair, but some members complained how it was unfair Shiro forfeited. I hardly see how it isn't fair, especially considering she asked to forfeit, and it tied us. BUT WHATEVER. Anywho =] It's my AMV pitted against Shiro-Chan's Mine: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I9xkzyPW9Cg Shiro-Chan's: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSiCx5zhhM4 Got it? You know the rules first to 6 wins, 0-5 = rape. Begin!!

08/29/06, 01:38 AM	#2
Hellpark Premium Member Join Date: Oct 2004 Age: 16 Posts: 2,248 Rep Power: 6	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip My vote is for Eclipse. The other one seems boring and dull because of the music and I lost interest by the middle. Eclipses seems to fit the AMV better and its just more entertaining to me.

08/29/06, 02:12 AM	#3
LimitLess Returned Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: USA Posts: 3,132 Rep Power: 8	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip Eclipse- AMV was pretty good. It flowed nicely. Nice song choice, and your clips went well with the lyrics at times. There were quite a few random clips, but overall good job. Shiro- Ahhh I don't know if it was your first or not because I haven't seen you make one before, but it was alright. The song was what ruined it. It became dull and just plain. You seem to have the concept of following beat, but it was just boring. Eclipse GMV

08/29/06, 09:24 PM	#5
Meilin Hao-Sama's Chibi Delilah Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Half of me is in New York City.... Age: 19 Posts: 5,862 Rep Power: 10	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip Agreeing with the others. Shiro had beat sync down, but I prefer the lyric-sync, so my vote is for E-CHAN GMV

08/30/06, 02:07 AM	#6
ansemx18 Keyblade Wielder Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: somewhere.... Age: 19 Posts: 231 Rep Power: 0	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip I dont think that Nickelback fit the first one and chans was just slow and they both lost my attention. If there are any more of these amv competitions id like to show off mine.

08/30/06, 02:33 AM	#7
LimitLess Returned Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: USA Posts: 3,132 Rep Power: 8	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip Hey buddy you need to vote or not post at all. There are more AMV competitions but we already have our selected few and this is a battle between two clans, which im sure you not into right this moment.

08/30/06, 09:56 AM	#8
tux_ Guest Posts: n/a	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip Honestly, I didn't really like either of them much. Eclipse: Didn't interest me. The whole thing seemed a little forced. Shiro: Albeit a little dull, it was still a beautiful AMV. Loved the part where you kept in the in-game talking. Shiro GMV

09/08/06, 02:29 AM	#9
D2L In This Crazy World... Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Tryna beat life cuz I can't cheat death Age: 15 Posts: 2,625 Rep Power: 6	Re: TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition Shiro vs. Ecip Eclipse: even thoughyou used a Nickleback song for a KH vid (which in my book is EXTREMELY overrated now) I think it was good. Shiro: It was just dull, I liked the concept and all just choose a diff. song next time. Eclipses ftw.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode