TNYvsFDD AMV Battle Competition #1

[Eclipse]

Since Shiro-Chan forfeitted, and we forfeitted, we are now tied at 5-5

Next up, AMV battle between HeartlessWhisper and Chaywa

HeartlessWhisper:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3i4kP1_IpxM

Chaywa:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UH1y-JYVSzo

First to 6 wins

5-0 = rape

Rules:
*no spamming
*no flaming
*no insulting others work
*must critique AMV
*no being biased

Let the games begin *thunderclap*

[Color Me Evil]

No being biased either.

Honestly, HeartlessWhisper gmv. Although the song choice could've been better, everything flowed wonderfully. The timing was great in every aspect. Having all FMV shots really makes this work.

Chaywa, I really hated how you switched between regular Sora (non FMV), FMV, and in-battle clips. =_= It got annoying. Another thing that annoyed me was how you constantly stopped the flow of one clip and brought it instantly to the end. It got on my nerve. I was actually getting angry and annoyed while watching your AMV.

[Chihiro]

I agree with the whole "being biased" thing.

Anyway, Heartless Whisper GMV. Although I'm not the biggest fan of Hilary Duff, your video had a wonderful flow to it, and the timing with some of the clips were just wonderful. Actually, the lyrics of the song really fit Kingdom Hearts, so even your song choice wasn't that bad. I guess I just don't like Hilary when she sings ^^;;

Chaywa, I felt that your video was sort of random. Some clips fit well with the song while some didn't do it justice. Sorry ^^

[TheTerrorofDeath]

Heartless Whisper- I thought it was alright. Song choice could of been a whole lot better, and I thought it lost it for ya. I didn't see alot of your clips fit in too well with the lyrics nor the beat. At 2:39-2:45 there was a white blank which you need to go back and fix. I also didn't like some of the random fade effects you had. I wasn't fond of the ending either.

Chaywa- I really love this video for how limited you were to the effects you could use. You showed immense timing and a large amount of patience you put into it. The song was a pretty good choice and I've already discussed what I've thought of this AMV before.

So Chaywa GMV.

[Dogenzaka]

HeartlessWhisper - Very nice, everything flowed pretty nicely. Although it feels like you slowed the clips a bit so it felt a bit slow. Also you let some clips play a little too long in my opinion, but that's just how I feel. But I really liked the song, I haven't heard it since Hilary Duff's album first hit. Fit the theme quite nicely. Everything flowed well.

chaywa - Wow. Astounding. You kept it at a nice rhythm not too slow not too fast, and I loved the song. It certainly fit well with the clips. And I loved how you kept it well on beat, especially with the drum. Everything was well paced and the clips were well chosen. Fit almost perfectly. My complaint would only have to be some clips were a bit random.

Tough decision, but chaywa gets my vote.

[Hellpark]

Heartless Whisper for me. Song matches the softness of the video. The animation the other one is bad and lacking smoothness. Thhis one seems good. Heartless gets my vote.

[Hiei-chan]

HEARTLESS WHISPER GMV

well i really didnt like the song to much but the scenes flowed nicely,the timing was good, an even though the song wasnt my favorites it still matched nicely

Chaywa ur AMV kickass an so did the song, but some of the scenes sorta just paused, i no u probably did that on purpose to follow the beat of the song, i still didnt like how it paused

thats why...

Heartless Whisper GMV

[Hip-Hop]

Both of them were a little, meh to me but I have to say Chaywa GMV

[Dogenzaka]

Does that make....wait

So Chaywa has 3 and HW has 4? .__. this thread has been up a long time.